Best Mattress Brands in Sarasota, Florida [2025 Guide]

Quick Brand Comparison

Here's a quick overview of the top mattress brands available in Sarasota, from luxury memory foam to traditional innerspring options that cater to different sleep needs and budgets.

Best Mattress Brands Available in Sarasota

Sarasota residents have access to an impressive selection of quality mattress brands across the city's numerous furniture and mattress retailers. From the luxury shops near University Town Center to the family-owned stores along Tamiami Trail, you'll find options for every sleep style and budget.

Serta

Serta has been a trusted name in sleep for over 90 years, offering a comprehensive range from their popular Perfect Sleeper line to luxury iComfort memory foam mattresses. Their mattresses excel in motion isolation and back support, making them particularly popular with couples and back sleepers.

Best for: Back sleepers seeking motion isolation and spinal alignment
Price Range: $$ - Mid-range
Available locally at: Rooms To Go in Sarasota, Mattresses & More, and Ashley Store

Tempur-Pedic

The original memory foam mattress company, Tempur-Pedic uses proprietary TEMPUR material that conforms precisely to your body shape and weight. Their mattresses are particularly beneficial for people with joint pain, arthritis, or pressure point issues, as research shows that proper spinal alignment can reduce back pain.

Best for: Side sleepers with joint pain and pressure point relief needs
Price Range: $$$ - Luxury
Available locally at: Tempur-Pedic Flagship Store at University Town Center, Matter Brothers Furniture & Design, and Mattress Firm Sarasota

Stearns & Foster

This luxury mattress brand combines traditional craftsmanship with modern comfort technologies, featuring hand-tufted details and premium materials like silk, cashmere, and high-grade memory foams. Stearns & Foster mattresses are handcrafted and offer exceptional durability and sophisticated comfort.

Best for: Luxury seekers who want traditional craftsmanship with modern comfort
Price Range: $$$ - Luxury
Available locally at: Rooms To Go in Sarasota, Ashley Store, and multiple Mattress Firm locations

Simmons

Famous for inventing the pocketed coil system, Simmons Beautyrest mattresses feature individually wrapped coils that move independently to reduce motion transfer. This technology makes them excellent for couples, as movement on one side of the bed doesn't disturb the other sleeper.

Best for: Couples needing motion isolation and edge support
Price Range: $$ - Mid-range
Available locally at: Rooms To Go, Mattresses & More, and Ashley Store

Beautyrest

Beautyrest mattresses feature the brand's signature pocketed coil technology combined with cooling materials like gel memory foam and breathable fabrics. They're particularly well-suited for Florida's warm climate, offering temperature regulation that many Sarasota residents appreciate year-round.

Best for: Hot sleepers and combination sleepers who change positions frequently
Price Range: $$ - Mid-range
Available locally at: Rooms To Go, Ashley Store, and Mattresses & More

Bedgear

Bedgear takes a performance-based approach to sleep, designing mattresses with advanced cooling technology and moisture-wicking fabrics. Originally developed for athletes, their mattresses focus on temperature regulation and recovery, making them popular with active Sarasota residents who enjoy the area's outdoor lifestyle.

Best for: Athletes and hot sleepers needing advanced cooling technology
Price Range: $$$ - Premium
Available locally at: Rooms To Go, Kane's Furniture, and Hudson's Furniture + Mattress

Restonic

A family-owned American company, Restonic offers quality mattresses at accessible prices without compromising on comfort or support. Their mattresses feature responsive coil systems and pressure-relieving foams, providing good value for budget-conscious shoppers who still want quality construction.

Best for: Value-conscious shoppers seeking quality back support
Price Range: $ - Budget-friendly
Available locally at: The Furniture Warehouse and CITY Furniture

Sierra Sleep by Ashley

Ashley's in-house mattress line offers reliable comfort at budget-friendly prices, featuring both memory foam and innerspring options. These mattresses provide basic comfort and support features without premium pricing, making them popular with young families and first-time mattress buyers.

Best for: Budget-conscious families and first-time buyers
Price Range: $ - Budget-friendly
Available locally at: Mattress Firm Sarasota-Bee Ridge, Mattress Firm Sarasota, and other Mattress Firm locations

Sleepy's

Sleepy's offers straightforward, no-frills mattresses that focus on basic comfort and support at affordable prices. Their mattresses are designed for customers who want reliable sleep without complex features or premium materials, making them a practical choice for guest rooms or starter mattresses.

Best for: Basic comfort needs and guest room setups
Price Range: $ - Budget-friendly
Available locally at: Mattress Firm Sarasota II, Mattress Firm Clearance Center, and other Mattress Firm locations

Coastal Living

Designed specifically for Florida's coastal lifestyle, Coastal Living mattresses emphasize breathability and moisture resistance. These mattresses feature cooling technologies and materials that handle humidity well, making them particularly suitable for Sarasota's climate and proximity to Siesta Beach and other coastal areas.

Best for: Florida residents wanting climate-appropriate comfort and breathability
Price Range: $$ - Mid-range
Available locally at: The Furniture Warehouse locations on both Tamiami Trail and North Washington Boulevard

Understanding Mattress Types and Sleep Health

Choosing the right mattress type significantly impacts your sleep quality and overall health. Different materials and constructions serve various sleep needs, from pressure relief to temperature regulation.

Memory Foam for Pressure Relief

Memory foam mattresses contour to your body's curves, distributing weight evenly and reducing pressure points. This makes them particularly beneficial for side sleepers, who need cushioning for hips and shoulders. Studies indicate that proper pressure distribution can improve sleep quality and reduce tossing and turning. Brands like Tempur-Pedic and Serta's iComfort line excel in this category, offering various firmness levels to accommodate different preferences.

Hybrid Mattresses for Support and Comfort

Hybrid mattresses combine the contouring benefits of foam with the support and bounce of innerspring coils. This combination works well for combination sleepers who change positions throughout the night, as it provides both pressure relief and responsive support. Sleep experts recommend hybrid constructions for people who want the benefits of memory foam without feeling "stuck" in one position. Many Beautyrest and Simmons models feature this hybrid design.

Innerspring for Traditional Sleepers

Traditional innerspring mattresses offer firm support and excellent airflow, making them ideal for hot sleepers and those who prefer a more traditional feel. The coil systems provide responsive support that makes changing positions easy, and the open structure allows air to circulate freely. Back and stomach sleepers often prefer the firmer support that quality innerspring mattresses provide, as they help maintain proper spinal alignment without excessive sinking.

Firmness and Sleep Position

Your preferred sleep position should guide your firmness choice, as medical research shows that proper spinal alignment during sleep can prevent back pain and improve sleep quality. Side sleepers typically need medium to medium-soft mattresses to cushion pressure points, while back sleepers benefit from medium-firm support that maintains the spine's natural curve. Stomach sleepers usually require firmer surfaces to prevent their midsection from sinking too deeply. Use our mattress size calculator to determine the right size for your space, and check our comprehensive buying guide for detailed firmness recommendations.

Where to Buy These Brands Locally

Sarasota offers numerous options for mattress shopping, from large furniture chains to specialized sleep stores. The highest concentration of retailers is along South Tamiami Trail, making it easy to compare multiple brands in one shopping trip.

Rooms To Go in Sarasota carries the widest selection of major brands including Serta, Stearns & Foster, Simmons, and Beautyrest, making it a one-stop destination for comparing top mattress brands. The Mattress Firm chain has multiple Sarasota locations, including Mattress Firm Sarasota-Bee Ridge and Mattress Firm Sarasota, specializing in sleep-focused brands like Tempur-Pedic, Serta, and their exclusive Sierra Sleep line. For a more boutique experience, Matter Brothers Furniture & Design offers premium brands with personalized service, while the Tempur-Pedic flagship store at University Town Center provides the full range of their memory foam collection.

Before visiting stores, review our buying checklist to prepare for your shopping trip and ensure you ask the right questions about warranties, sleep trials, and delivery options.

Prefer Shopping Online?

If you'd rather skip the store visits, Sleepology offers a compelling alternative. They carry many premium mattress brands with commission-free pricing (no sales commissions added to prices), a "double-the-difference" price match guarantee, and their Price Predictor™ tool ensures you're getting the best deal. It's a transparent, no-pressure shopping experience with white-glove delivery. Use code DELIVERY for free delivery: Shop Sleepology.