Best Mattress Brands in Tallahassee, Florida [2025 Guide]

Quick Brand Comparison

Here's a quick overview of the top mattress brands available locally in Tallahassee, helping you narrow down your options based on your specific sleep needs and budget.

Best Mattress Brands Available in Tallahassee

Beautyrest

Beautyrest pioneered the pocketed coil technology that remains their signature feature today. Their Black series offers premium hybrid construction with advanced cooling and motion isolation, while their Silver and Platinum lines provide excellent value for quality sleep technology.

Best for: Side sleepers who need motion isolation and couples with different sleep preferences
Price Range: $$$ - Premium
Available locally at: Ashley Store, Mattress Firm Tallahassee North, and three other Mattress Firm locations

Serta

Serta combines memory foam comfort with advanced cooling technology in their iComfort and Perfect Sleeper lines. Their mattresses excel at temperature regulation while providing the contouring support that memory foam sleepers love, making them particularly effective for those dealing with joint pain.

Best for: Back pain sufferers and hot sleepers needing memory foam comfort
Price Range: $$ - Mid-range to Premium
Available locally at: Ashley Store, Mattress Firm Tallahassee, and multiple other locations

Simmons

Simmons offers versatile mattress construction across their Beautyrest Recharge and ComforPedic lines. Their hybrid designs balance traditional innerspring support with modern foam comfort layers, creating mattresses that work well for various sleep positions and body types.

Best for: Combination sleepers and those wanting traditional spring support with modern comfort
Price Range: $$ - Mid-range
Available locally at: Mattress Firm Clearance Center North Monroe Street, Asher Outlet, and other local retailers

Stearns & Foster

Stearns & Foster represents luxury mattress craftsmanship with hand-tufted construction and premium materials like cashmere, silk, and high-grade memory foams. Their Estate and Lux Estate collections offer hotel-quality sleep experiences with exceptional durability and comfort.

Best for: Luxury seekers and those prioritizing premium materials and craftsmanship
Price Range: $$$$ - Luxury
Available locally at: Ashley Store, Mattress Firm Tallahassee North

Tempur-Pedic

Tempur-Pedic's proprietary TEMPUR material responds to body heat and weight to provide personalized support and pressure relief. Their mattresses are particularly beneficial for those with chronic pain conditions, as the material helps reduce pressure points while maintaining spinal alignment throughout the night.

Best for: Chronic pain sufferers, pressure point relief, and those needing therapeutic support
Price Range: $$$$ - Premium
Available locally at: Mattress Firm Tallahassee, Ashley Store

Sealy

Sealy's Posturepedic technology targets the heaviest part of your body with reinforced support, while their hybrid models combine this with memory foam comfort layers. Their Response and Conform collections offer traditional innerspring feel with modern enhancements for better sleep quality.

Best for: Traditional innerspring lovers and back sleepers needing extra lumbar support
Price Range: $$ - Mid-range
Available locally at: Mattress Firm Tallahassee North, Asher Outlet

Nectar

Nectar focuses on affordable memory foam mattresses with cooling gel infusions and breathable covers. Their direct-to-consumer model allows them to offer quality memory foam at accessible prices, making premium sleep technology available to budget-conscious shoppers.

Best for: Hot sleepers on a budget and those new to memory foam
Price Range: $ - Budget-friendly
Available locally at: Ashley Store, BoxDrop Tallahassee Furniture Direct

Avocado

Avocado specializes in organic and eco-friendly mattresses using natural latex, organic cotton, and wool. Their mattresses provide excellent temperature regulation and pressure relief while meeting strict environmental and health standards, appealing to those with chemical sensitivities or environmental concerns.

Best for: Eco-conscious sleepers, those with chemical sensitivities, and natural material preferences
Price Range: $$$ - Premium
Available locally at: Asher Outlet

Amerisleep

Amerisleep designs mattresses specifically for active lifestyles and recovery, using plant-based memory foams that provide faster response and better temperature regulation than traditional memory foam. Their AS series offers different firmness levels to match various sleep preferences and recovery needs.

Best for: Active individuals, athletes needing recovery support, and responsive memory foam lovers
Price Range: $$$ - Premium
Available locally at: Asher Outlet

Purple

Purple's unique gel grid technology provides exceptional airflow and pressure relief with a distinctive bouncy feel that's unlike traditional memory foam or springs. Their mattresses excel at temperature regulation while offering targeted support that adapts to different body areas.

Best for: Hot sleepers wanting unique feel, those who dislike memory foam sinking sensation
Price Range: $$$ - Premium
Available locally at: Mattress Firm Clearance Center North Monroe Street, Ashley Store

Understanding Mattress Types and Sleep Health

Choosing the right mattress type is essential for quality sleep and long-term health. Different constructions serve different sleep needs, and understanding these differences helps you make an informed decision for your specific situation.

Memory Foam for Pressure Relief

Memory foam mattresses excel at conforming to your body's contours, distributing weight evenly and reducing pressure points that can cause discomfort and interrupt sleep. This makes them particularly beneficial for side sleepers, who often experience pressure buildup at the hips and shoulders. Research shows that proper pressure relief can significantly improve sleep quality and reduce morning stiffness. Modern memory foams also incorporate cooling technologies to address traditional heat retention concerns.

Hybrid Mattresses for Support and Comfort

Hybrid mattresses combine pocketed coils with foam comfort layers, offering the support benefits of innerspring with the pressure relief of memory foam. This construction works particularly well for combination sleepers who change positions throughout the night, as the coils provide responsive support while foam layers cushion pressure points. Sleep experts note that proper spinal alignment across different sleep positions is critical for preventing back pain and ensuring restorative sleep.

Innerspring for Traditional Sleepers

Traditional innerspring mattresses provide firm support with excellent airflow, making them ideal for hot sleepers and those who prefer a more traditional sleep surface. The coil construction allows air to circulate freely, helping regulate body temperature throughout the night. These mattresses work well for back and stomach sleepers who need consistent support without significant contouring.

Firmness and Sleep Position

Mattress firmness directly impacts spinal alignment and pressure point relief, making it critical to match firmness to your primary sleep position. Side sleepers typically benefit from medium to medium-soft mattresses that allow the hips and shoulders to sink slightly, while back sleepers often prefer medium-firm support. Research indicates that proper firmness selection can reduce back pain and improve sleep quality. Use our mattress size calculator and comprehensive buying guide to help determine the right firmness for your needs.

Where to Buy These Brands Locally

Tallahassee offers several excellent retailers where you can test and purchase quality mattress brands. The city's mattress shopping scene centers around major retailers with multiple locations, giving you plenty of opportunities to compare different brands and models in person.

Ashley Store on Capital Circle SE carries the widest selection of premium brands including Beautyrest, Serta, Tempur-Pedic, and Purple, making it an excellent starting point for comparison shopping. The Mattress Firm locations, including Mattress Firm Tallahassee North on Thomasville Road and Mattress Firm Tallahassee on South Magnolia Drive, offer extensive selections with knowledgeable staff to help you navigate different comfort levels and features.

For unique brands and potentially better pricing, Asher Outlet on Capital Circle NE stands out as the only local retailer carrying Avocado and Amerisleep, along with other premium options. Before making your final decision, review our mattress buying checklist to ensure you're asking the right questions and testing mattresses properly during your store visits.

Prefer Shopping Online?

If you'd rather skip the store visits, Sleepology offers a compelling alternative. They carry many premium mattress brands with commission-free pricing (no sales commissions added to prices), a "double-the-difference" price match guarantee, and their Price Predictor™ tool ensures you're getting the best deal. It's a transparent, no-pressure shopping experience with white-glove delivery. Use code DELIVERY for free delivery: Shop Sleepology.