Quick Mattress Store Comparisons
| Store Name | Specialty | Price Range | Best For |
|---|
| Bob's Discount Furniture and Mattress Store | Budget-friendly mattresses | $ | Value shoppers |
| Steinhafels | Premium furniture & mattresses | $$-$$$ | Quality seekers |
| Van Vreede's Appliance, Furniture & Mattresses, Inc. | Local family business | $$ | Personal service |
| WG&R Furniture | Traditional furniture store | $$ | Established brands |
| Ashley Store | National furniture chain | $-$$ | Wide selection |
| Mattress Firm Appleton West | Mattress specialist | $$-$$$ | Expert guidance |
Top Mattress Stores in Appleton
Steinhafels
This Wisconsin-based furniture retailer has been serving the Fox Cities area for decades and maintains one of the most comprehensive mattress selections in Appleton. Located on West Grande Market Drive, Steinhafels carries premium brands like Tempur-Pedic, Sealy, and Beautyrest alongside mid-range options. Their showroom is spacious and well-organized, making it easy to compare different models side by side.
Queen mattresses typically range from $800-2500, with financing options available for higher-end purchases. They're particularly strong in the luxury segment and often have exclusive models you won't find at other local stores.
Best for: Shoppers seeking premium mattresses with extensive selection and local reputation
Contact: 4750 W Grande Market Dr, Appleton, WI 54913
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 920-733-1000
Van Vreede's Appliance, Furniture & Mattresses, Inc.
This family-owned business on West College Avenue has been serving Appleton since the 1950s, giving them deep roots in the community. While they're known for appliances, their mattress section offers a curated selection focused on quality over quantity. The staff tends to know their products inside and out, and they're particularly good at matching customers with the right firmness level.
Their mattress prices are competitive for the mid-range market, with queens typically running $600-1200. They focus on established brands and often provide more personalized service than the larger chain stores.
Best for: Customers who value personal service and local business relationships
Contact: 2450 W College Ave, Appleton, WI 54914
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 920-730-4477
WG&R Furniture
Located on West Wisconsin Avenue, WG&R operates as a traditional furniture store with a solid mattress department. They've been in business for years and focus on carrying recognizable brand names that customers trust. The store layout is straightforward, and they maintain good relationships with manufacturers for special ordering.
Pricing falls in the middle range with queen mattresses typically between $700-1400. They're particularly good for customers who want to bundle mattress purchases with bedroom furniture, often offering package deals.
Best for: Shoppers looking to furnish entire bedrooms with coordinated pieces
Contact: 3810 W Wisconsin Ave, Appleton, WI 54914
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 920-738-5560
Ashley Store
The Ashley location on West Lawrence Street brings the national chain's extensive catalog to Appleton shoppers. They carry Ashley's full line of mattresses including their Chime memory foam series and hybrid models. The store is modern and well-lit, making it easy to browse their selection, and they frequently run promotional financing offers.
Queen mattresses range from about $500-1200, with frequent sales bringing prices down further. They stock a good variety of firmness levels and materials, from traditional innerspring to all-foam constructions.
Best for: Shoppers who want consistent national brand quality with frequent sales
Contact: 4731 W Lawrence St, Appleton, WI 54914
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 920-968-0013
Mattress Firm Appleton West
Located on North Mall Drive, this Mattress Firm location specializes exclusively in sleep products, which shows in their staff expertise and selection depth. They carry major brands like Purple, Serta, Sealy, and Tempur-Pedic with a good range of models in each line. Their sales associates are trained specifically in sleep science and can help with more technical questions about materials and construction.
Queen prices typically range from $600-2000, with their sleep trial and warranty programs being particularly comprehensive. They often have competitive financing options and their delivery service is reliable.
Best for: Customers who want specialized mattress expertise and comprehensive brand selection
Contact: 141 N Mall Dr, Appleton, WI 54913
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 920-882-5210
Delivery Considerations
Most Appleton mattress stores offer delivery within the Fox Cities area, typically charging $50-150 depending on the store and distance. Steinhafels and Mattress Firm generally provide the most reliable delivery windows, often offering morning or afternoon slots rather than all-day windows. Many stores will waive delivery fees on purchases over certain thresholds, usually $999 or higher.
Old mattress removal and haul-away services are available at most locations for an additional $25-75. Some stores like Bob's Discount Furniture include basic delivery setup, while others charge extra for services like carrying the mattress upstairs or setting up adjustable bases. When shopping, always confirm what's included in delivery and factor these costs into your budget calculations early in the process.
Mattress Buying Guide
Understanding Firmness Levels
Firmness is probably the most important factor in mattress satisfaction, but it's also the most subjective. What feels firm to one person might feel soft to another based on body weight, sleeping position, and personal preference. Most manufacturers use a 1-10 scale where 1 is extremely soft and 10 is extremely firm, though this isn't standardized across brands.
Side sleepers typically prefer softer mattresses (3-6 on the firmness scale) to allow hip and shoulder pressure relief, while stomach sleepers usually need firmer support (6-8) to prevent their midsection from sinking too much. Back sleepers often do well in the middle range (5-7), but your specific needs depend on your body type and any pain issues you're dealing with.
Size Selection Strategy
Room dimensions obviously matter, but many Appleton shoppers underestimate how much space they actually need for comfortable sleep. A queen mattress is 60x80 inches, but you need at least 2-3 feet of walking space around the bed for the room to feel comfortable. King mattresses add 16 inches of width, which can make a significant difference in smaller bedrooms common in older Appleton homes.
Consider your sleeping habits too. If you or your partner tends to spread out or move around during sleep, the extra space of a queen or king can dramatically improve sleep quality. Our comprehensive size guide can help you think through the practical considerations beyond just fitting the mattress in your room.
Budget Planning
Mattress pricing in Appleton varies widely, but you can generally expect to spend $800-1500 for a quality queen mattress that will last 7-10 years. Going below $600 often means compromising on materials or construction quality, while spending over $2000 typically gets you luxury features that may or may not improve your actual sleep experience.
Don't forget to budget for accessories. A good mattress protector runs $50-100, and if you need a new foundation or bed frame, add another $150-400. Many stores offer package deals that can save money if you need multiple items. Before making any major purchase, it's worth checking our detailed buying guide for current market insights and timing recommendations.
Prefer Shopping Online?
If you'd rather skip the showroom experience entirely, Sleepology offers a compelling online alternative with several advantages over traditional mattress shopping. Their commission-free pricing structure means you're not paying extra for sales commissions, and their "double-the-difference" price match guarantee ensures competitive pricing. The Price Predictor tool helps you find the best possible price without the typical haggle-heavy experience of mattress stores.
What sets Sleepology apart is their educational approach and transparent pricing. You get access to premium mattress brands all in one place without high-pressure sales tactics. They offer in-home white glove delivery and currently provide free delivery with code DELIVERY. For Appleton residents who value a clean, no-haggle shopping experience, Sleepology's approach can save both time and money while still ensuring you get expert guidance in selecting the right mattress.