Quick Mattress Store Comparisons
| Store Name | Specialty | Price Range | Best For |
|---|
| Simple Home Plus | Furniture & Mattresses | $$ - $$$ | One-stop home shopping |
| Slumberland Furniture | Sleep specialists | $$ - $$$$ | Wide selection & financing |
| Big Sandy Superstore | Furniture superstore | $ - $$$ | Budget-friendly options |
| Patrick Furniture & Mattress | Local family business | $$ - $$$$ | Personal service |
| BoxDrop Mattress Cape Girardeau | Factory-direct mattresses | $ - $$$ | Direct-to-consumer savings |
| Sleep Number | Adjustable firmness | $$$ - $$$$ | Customizable comfort |
Top Mattress Stores in Cape Girardeau
Simple Home Plus
Located on William Street, Simple Home Plus offers a comprehensive selection of mattresses alongside furniture and home accessories. They focus on providing quality sleep solutions with personalized service that Cape Girardeau residents have come to trust.
You'll find queens starting around $600, with premium options reaching $1,500+. They carry both traditional innerspring and modern memory foam options.
Best for: Shoppers wanting furniture and mattresses in one trip
Contact: 3049 William St #300, Cape Girardeau, MO 63703
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-573-203-5818
Slumberland Furniture
Slumberland has been a trusted name in sleep for decades, and their Cape Girardeau location continues that tradition. They specialize exclusively in sleep solutions with knowledgeable staff who understand the science of quality rest.
Queen mattresses typically start around $500 and go up to $2,000+ for luxury models. They offer extensive financing options and frequent sales events.
Best for: Sleep-focused expertise and financing flexibility
Contact: 2106 William St #200, Cape Girardeau, MO 63703
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-573-334-7757
Big Sandy Superstore
Right on South Main Street, Big Sandy Superstore brings big-box selection to Cape Girardeau shoppers. This furniture superstore model means competitive pricing and a wide range of mattress brands under one roof.
Their queen mattresses start as low as $300 for basic models, with mid-range options around $800. They're particularly strong in the budget to mid-range categories.
Best for: Budget-conscious shoppers and variety seekers
Contact: 43 S Main St, Cape Girardeau, MO 63703
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-573-334-6251
Patrick Furniture & Mattress
A local Cape Girardeau institution on North Kingshighway, Patrick Furniture & Mattress has been serving the community for years with personalized service. They know their customers by name and take pride in matching people with the perfect sleep solution.
Queen mattresses typically range from $600 to $1,800, with a focus on quality brands and customer satisfaction. Their staff takes time to understand your specific needs.
Best for: Personal service and local business support
Contact: 1140 N Kingshighway St, Cape Girardeau, MO 63701
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-573-334-6146
BoxDrop Mattress Cape Girardeau
BoxDrop operates on a factory-direct model, cutting out middleman markups to offer better prices on quality mattresses. Their South Kingshighway location focuses purely on sleep products with no-pressure sales approach.
Queens start around $400 and top out around $1,200. The factory-direct model means you're getting manufacturer pricing on name-brand mattresses.
Best for: Factory-direct savings and straightforward shopping
Contact: 345 S Kingshighway Suite B, Cape Girardeau, MO 63703
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-573-482-2711
Sleep Number
The Sleep Number store on Siemers Drive specializes in their signature adjustable firmness technology. Each side of the bed can be customized to individual preferences, making it ideal for couples with different comfort needs.
Queen Sleep Number beds start around $1,000 and can reach $3,000+ for their premium smart bed models with sleep tracking and automatic adjustments.
Best for: Couples with different firmness preferences and tech-savvy sleepers
Contact: 157 Siemers Dr Suite 108, Cape Girardeau, MO 63701
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-573-803-4277
Delivery Considerations
Most Cape Girardeau mattress stores offer delivery within a 20-mile radius, which covers the greater Cape area including Jackson, Scott City, and surrounding communities. Standard delivery fees range from $50 to $100, though many stores waive delivery on purchases over $500.
Delivery windows typically span 2-4 hours, with most stores offering morning or afternoon slots. Weekend delivery is available but may cost extra. Many stores also offer old mattress haul-away service for $25-50, which is worth it considering Missouri disposal regulations.
Setup service (moving your new mattress to the bedroom and unwrapping) is usually included, but white-glove service (full setup including bed frame assembly) may cost additional. Before your delivery date, use our mattress delivery checklist to ensure everything goes smoothly.
Mattress Buying Guide
Understanding Firmness Levels
Firmness is subjective, but generally ranges from 1-10 with 1 being ultra-soft and 10 being rock-hard. Most people prefer medium-firm (around 6-7) as it supports proper spinal alignment while providing pressure relief.
Side sleepers typically need softer mattresses (4-6) to accommodate hip and shoulder pressure points. Back and stomach sleepers usually prefer firmer options (6-8) for better support. Don't rely solely on labels - always test in-store when possible.
Keep in mind that mattresses often feel different after a few weeks of use. Most quality mattresses have an adjustment period of 2-4 weeks as materials settle and your body adapts.
Size Selection Strategy
Queen mattresses are Cape Girardeau's most popular choice, fitting most bedrooms while providing ample space for couples. However, measure your room before deciding - you need at least 2 feet of walkway space around the bed.
King mattresses require larger bedrooms (ideally 12x12 feet minimum) but provide the most sleeping space. California kings are longer but narrower than standard kings. Our detailed size guide can help you choose the perfect dimensions for your space and sleeping arrangements.
Consider your ceiling height if you're adding a box spring or adjustable base. Standard ceiling height of 8 feet works fine, but vaulted or low ceilings may affect your options.
Budget Planning
Quality mattresses in Cape Girardeau range from $300 for basic models to $3,000+ for luxury options. A good rule of thumb is to budget $500-1,200 for a queen mattress that will last 7-10 years.
Don't forget additional costs: delivery ($50-100), mattress protector ($50-150), and potentially new sheets if you're changing sizes. Many stores offer package deals that include these accessories at a discount.
Use our mattress budget calculator to determine how much to spend based on your sleep priorities and financial situation. Remember that you spend roughly one-third of your life in bed, making a quality mattress a worthwhile investment in your health and daily performance.
Prefer Shopping Online?
If you prefer shopping from home, Sleepology offers an excellent alternative to traditional mattress stores. They eliminate sales commissions that typically get added to mattress prices, passing those savings directly to customers through their commission-free pricing model.
Their "Double-the-difference" price match guarantee and Price Predictor tool ensure you're getting the best possible deal. You'll find premium mattress brands all in one place without dealing with high-pressure salespeople. The clean, no-haggle pricing experience makes mattress shopping straightforward and transparent.
Sleepology provides in-home white glove delivery service, and Cape Girardeau residents can get free delivery using code DELIVERY. Check out their current offerings and claim your free delivery to experience hassle-free mattress shopping from the comfort of your home.