Best Mattress Stores in Columbus, Ohio [2025 Guide]

Quick Mattress Store Comparisons

Top Mattress Stores in Columbus

Big Sandy Superstore

This regional furniture and mattress chain has built a solid reputation across Ohio with their no-nonsense approach to home furnishing. Located right on Polaris Parkway, they carry a good selection of name-brand mattresses alongside their furniture inventory.

You'll find queen mattresses starting around $400-600 for basic models, with premium options reaching $1,500-2,000. They typically stock brands like Sealy, Serta, and Beautyrest.

Best for: Shoppers looking to furnish multiple rooms or who want furniture and mattress package deals
Contact: 1180 Polaris Pkwy, Columbus, OH 43240
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 614-430-8962

Ashley Store

Ashley's Columbus locations focus heavily on complete bedroom sets, making them ideal if you're starting from scratch. Their mattress selection complements their furniture lines, with both budget and mid-range options available.

Queen mattresses typically start around $500-700, with their signature collections running $800-1,800. They often bundle mattresses with bed frames and bedroom furniture at competitive package prices.

Best for: Complete bedroom makeovers and customers who prefer coordinated furniture sets
Contact: Multiple locations
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 614-441-4566

Morris Home Furniture and Mattress

This Ohio-based furniture chain has been serving Columbus families for decades and really understands the local market. Their mattress departments are well-stocked with both popular and premium brands, plus they offer solid customer service.

Queen pricing starts around $600 for entry-level models, with luxury mattresses reaching $2,500-3,000. They carry Tempur-Pedic, Purple, and other specialty sleep brands alongside traditional innerspring options.

Best for: Shoppers who want local service with regional accountability and prefer supporting Ohio businesses
Contact: Multiple locations
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 614-441-4567

Sleep Outfitters of Columbus Gemini

These folks specialize exclusively in sleep, and it shows in their product knowledge and customer consultation approach. They take time to understand your sleep issues and preferences rather than pushing you toward the highest-priced option.

Queen mattresses start around $800-1,000 for quality options, with premium models reaching $3,000-4,000. They carry specialty brands like Tempur-Pedic, Sleep Number, and boutique manufacturers you won't find at big box stores.

Best for: People with specific sleep problems, couples with different comfort preferences, or anyone wanting expert sleep consultation
Contact: Multiple locations
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 614-436-4115

Mattress Firm Polaris Parkway

The national chain everyone knows, with consistent inventory and frequent sales promotions. Their Polaris location is convenient for north Columbus shoppers, and they typically have competitive pricing on major brands.

Queen mattresses start as low as $300-400 during sales, with mid-range options around $700-1,200. They carry all the major brands and often run buy-one-get-one deals or percentage-off promotions.

Best for: Budget shoppers, people who want familiar brand names, and customers who prefer straightforward pricing
Contact: Multiple locations
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 614-846-2770

American Freight Furniture, Mattress, Appliance

If budget is your primary concern, American Freight delivers no-frills mattress shopping with rock-bottom prices. Their Morse Road location stocks basic to mid-range mattresses at discount prices, though selection can be limited.

Queen mattresses start as low as $200-300, with their best options topping out around $800-1,000. Don't expect luxury brands, but you'll find solid value for basic comfort needs.

Best for: Tight budgets, guest rooms, temporary housing situations, or anyone prioritizing price over premium features
Contact: 900 Morse Rd, Columbus, OH 43229
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 614-430-0200

Delivery Considerations

Columbus mattress delivery typically takes 1-2 weeks for in-stock items, though some stores offer next-day or same-day delivery for an extra fee. Most retailers charge $75-150 for standard delivery, with free delivery often kicking in on purchases over $500-1,000.

Pay attention to what's included in delivery. Basic drop-off means they'll bring it to your door, while white glove service includes setup in your bedroom and removal of packaging. Old mattress haul-away usually costs an additional $25-50, but some stores include it free with delivery. Before making your purchase, use our mattress buying checklist to ensure you've covered all the delivery details.

If you live in areas like German Village with narrow streets or walk-up apartments near OSU, confirm the delivery team can actually get your mattress to your bedroom. Some Columbus neighborhoods have tricky access that requires special arrangements.

Mattress Buying Guide

Understanding Firmness Levels

Firmness is probably the most misunderstood aspect of mattress shopping. What feels "medium" to a 200-pound person will feel "firm" to someone who weighs 130 pounds. Your body weight, sleep position, and personal preference all factor into what firmness level will work best.

Side sleepers generally need softer mattresses to accommodate hip and shoulder curves, while back and stomach sleepers typically prefer firmer support. If you're shopping with a partner who has different preferences, look for mattresses with good motion isolation or consider split firmness options. Our comprehensive mattress buying guide breaks down firmness levels in detail.

Don't rely solely on in-store testing. Spending 5 minutes on a showroom mattress won't tell you how it'll feel after 8 hours of sleep. Look for generous sleep trial periods (90+ nights) so you can make sure your choice works in real-world conditions.

Size Selection Strategy

Columbus bedrooms vary wildly, from cramped Short North apartments to spacious Upper Arlington homes. Before mattress shopping, measure your bedroom and consider how much floor space you'll have left with a larger mattress.

Queen size works for most couples and fits in average-sized bedrooms, but if you're both over 6 feet tall or one of you moves around a lot during sleep, king size might be worth the investment. Just make sure you can get a king mattress up your staircase - many Columbus homes, especially in established neighborhoods, have narrow or curved stairs that make delivery challenging.

Single people often default to full size to save money, but queen offers significantly more space for less than $200 more in most cases. Use our mattress size guide to compare dimensions and see what works for your space and budget.

Budget Planning

A good mattress is a long-term investment - figure on using it for 7-10 years minimum. That $1,200 mattress breaks down to about $12-17 per month over its useful life, which puts the cost in perspective.

That said, you don't need to spend a fortune for good sleep. The $300-800 range offers solid options for most people, while $800-1,500 gets you premium materials and features. Above $1,500, you're paying for luxury touches that may or may not improve your actual sleep quality.

Factor in the total cost including delivery, tax, and any accessories you need. A $600 mattress becomes $750+ after delivery and tax. Many Columbus stores offer financing, but read the terms carefully - 0% financing is great if you can pay it off in time, but the deferred interest can be brutal if you miss the deadline.

Prefer Shopping Online?

If you'd rather skip the showroom experience entirely, Sleepology offers a compelling alternative for Columbus shoppers. They focus on transparent, commission-free pricing without the typical sales pressure you'll encounter at traditional mattress stores.

What sets them apart is their Price Predictor tool and double-the-difference price match guarantee, ensuring you get the best possible deal. They carry premium mattress brands all in one place with clean, no-haggle pricing and educational guidance to help you make the right choice. Plus, they offer white glove delivery right here in Columbus with free delivery using code DELIVERY. Visit their discount page to take advantage of this offer.