Quick Mattress Store Comparisons
Shopping for a new mattress in Tallahassee? Here's a quick comparison of the top local options to help you narrow down your search based on what matters most to you.
| Store Name | Specialty | Price Range | Best For |
|---|
| Ashley Store | Complete bedroom sets | $300-$2,000+ | One-stop furniture shopping |
| American Freight Furniture, Mattress, Appliance | Discount name brands | $200-$1,500 | Budget-conscious shoppers |
| Mattress Firm Tallahassee | Wide mattress selection | $400-$3,000+ | Brand variety and sleep trials |
| Mattress By Appointment | Factory-direct pricing | $250-$1,200 | Best value on quality mattresses |
| BoxDrop Tallahassee Furniture Direct | Overstock furniture | $300-$1,800 | Deep discounts on excess inventory |
| Capital Discount Bedding Inc | Local bedding specialist | $200-$1,500 | Personal service and local support |
Top Mattress Stores in Tallahassee
Ashley Store
Ashley Store on Capital Circle Southeast offers a comprehensive furniture shopping experience with a solid mattress selection. They're particularly strong if you're looking to furnish an entire bedroom, as you can coordinate your mattress purchase with bed frames, dressers, and nightstands all in one trip.
Queen mattresses typically start around $400 and go up to $2,000 or more for their premium memory foam and hybrid models. They carry their own Ashley Sleep line plus several national brands, with financing options available for larger purchases.
Best for: Complete bedroom makeovers and coordinated furniture sets
Contact: 1190 Capital Cir SE, Tallahassee, FL 32301
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-850-878-3095
American Freight Furniture, Mattress, Appliance
Located on West Tharpe Street, American Freight specializes in discounted name-brand mattresses and furniture. They're known for carrying overstock and discontinued models from major manufacturers, which means you can often find quality mattresses at significantly reduced prices.
Their inventory changes frequently, but you'll typically find queens starting around $250 for basic innerspring models and going up to $1,500 for memory foam and hybrid options. Same-day delivery is available, which is great when you need a mattress quickly.
Best for: Bargain hunters looking for name brands at discount prices
Contact: 3170 W Tharpe St, Tallahassee, FL 32303
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-850-504-1000
Mattress Firm Tallahassee
Mattress Firm operates multiple locations around Tallahassee and is the go-to choice for shoppers who want to test a wide variety of brands under one roof. They carry everything from budget-friendly options to luxury brands like Tempur-Pedic and Purple, with knowledgeable staff to help guide your decision.
Queen prices range from about $400 for their entry-level models up to $3,000+ for premium memory foam and smart mattresses. They offer sleep trials on most mattresses and frequently run promotions that include free pillows or sheets with purchase.
Best for: Shoppers who want maximum brand variety and sleep trial options
Contact: Multiple locations
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-850-309-0208
Mattress By Appointment
This factory-direct retailer on Apalachee Parkway cuts out the middleman to offer quality mattresses at warehouse prices. Their business model focuses on appointment-only shopping, which allows them to keep overhead low and pass the savings directly to customers.
Queen mattresses typically range from $300 to $1,200, with most options falling in the $400-$800 sweet spot for excellent value. They specialize in traditional innerspring and memory foam mattresses from manufacturers you might not find elsewhere in town.
Best for: Value seekers who want quality mattresses without retail markup
Contact: 2320 Apalachee Pkwy Unit G, Tallahassee, FL 32301
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-850-296-8167
BoxDrop Tallahassee Furniture Direct
BoxDrop specializes in selling excess inventory from major furniture manufacturers at steep discounts. Their Industrial Plaza location rotates stock frequently, so each visit might reveal different mattress brands and models at significantly reduced prices.
Pricing varies based on available inventory, but queens typically range from $350 to $1,800, often 30-60% below regular retail prices. The trade-off is that selection changes regularly, and you'll need to act quickly when you find something you like.
Best for: Flexible shoppers who want premium mattresses at deep discounts
Contact: 2855 Industrial Plaza Dr, Tallahassee, FL 32301
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-850-545-7112
Capital Discount Bedding Inc
This locally-owned bedding specialist on North Monroe Street has been serving Tallahassee for years with personalized service and competitive pricing. They focus exclusively on sleep products, which means their staff really knows mattresses inside and out.
Queen mattresses start around $250 for basic models and top out around $1,500 for premium options. As a local business, they're often more flexible on pricing and delivery arrangements than larger chains, and they stand behind their products with excellent customer service.
Best for: Shoppers who value personal service and supporting local businesses
Contact: 1901 N Monroe St, Tallahassee, FL 32303
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-850-385-5505
Delivery Considerations
Delivery policies vary significantly between Tallahassee mattress stores, so it's worth asking about specifics before you buy. Most stores offer delivery within 2-7 days, with same-day or next-day delivery available from some retailers for an additional fee.
Delivery fees typically range from $75-$150, though many stores waive delivery charges on purchases over a certain amount (usually $500-$1,000). Some retailers include basic setup, while others charge extra for services like moving your mattress to an upstairs bedroom or setting up an adjustable base.
Old mattress removal is another consideration. Most stores offer haul-away service for $25-$75, which is often worth it to avoid the hassle of disposing of your old mattress yourself. Before scheduling delivery, check our pre-purchase checklist to make sure you've covered all the important details.
Mattress Buying Guide
Understanding Firmness Levels
Firmness preference is highly personal, but there are some general guidelines that can help narrow your search. Side sleepers typically prefer softer mattresses (3-6 on a 1-10 scale) that allow hips and shoulders to sink in slightly, while back and stomach sleepers often need firmer support (6-8 on the scale) to maintain proper spinal alignment.
However, firmness isn't everything. The quality of support layers, pressure relief, and how the mattress responds to your specific body type matter just as much. That's why it's crucial to spend at least 10-15 minutes lying on any mattress you're considering, preferably in your normal sleeping position.
Size Selection Strategy
Queen mattresses are the most popular choice in Tallahassee, offering a good balance of space and affordability for couples or individuals who like extra room. However, don't automatically assume queen is right for you without considering your specific situation.
If you're tall (over 6'2"), have pets that sleep on the bed, or one partner is a restless sleeper, a king might be worth the extra investment. Conversely, if you're furnishing a guest room or apartment near FSU, a full-size mattress might better fit your space and budget constraints.
Our mattress size guide includes room dimension recommendations and detailed measurements to help you choose the right size for your space.
Budget Planning
A quality mattress is an investment in your health and comfort, but that doesn't mean you need to spend a fortune. In Tallahassee's market, you can find a good queen mattress for $400-$800 that will serve you well for 7-10 years.
Factor in additional costs like delivery, setup, old mattress removal, and any accessories you might need (mattress protector, new sheets, pillows). These extras can add $100-$300 to your total purchase, so budget accordingly.
Many stores offer financing options, but be cautious about 0% interest deals that turn into high-interest loans if not paid off in time. Use our mattress budget calculator to determine what monthly payment fits comfortably in your budget.
Prefer Shopping Online?
If you'd rather skip the showroom experience entirely, Sleepology offers a compelling online mattress buying experience with several advantages over traditional retail. Their commission-free pricing means you're not paying for pushy salespeople, and their "Double-the-difference" price match guarantee ensures you get the best deal available.
What sets Sleepology apart is their Price Predictor tool that helps ensure you're buying at the optimal time, plus they carry premium mattress brands all in one place without the high-pressure sales tactics. Their transparent, education-focused approach helps you make an informed decision from the comfort of your current bed. They offer white glove delivery throughout the Tallahassee area, and you can get free delivery with code DELIVERY at checkout.
![Best Mattress Stores in Tallahassee, Florida [2025 Guide] — hero image](https://euwpgvegcebisxlyfgfx.supabase.co/storage/v1/object/public/blog-images/image-1766124298752.png)
![Best Mattress Brands in Bowling Green, Kentucky [2025 Guide]](https://euwpgvegcebisxlyfgfx.supabase.co/storage/v1/object/public/blog-images/image-1766167587542.png)
![Best Mattress Stores in Bowling Green, Kentucky [2025 Guide]](https://euwpgvegcebisxlyfgfx.supabase.co/storage/v1/object/public/blog-images/image-1766167502283.png)
![Best Mattress Stores in Tallahassee, Florida [2025 Guide] — showroom image](https://euwpgvegcebisxlyfgfx.supabase.co/storage/v1/object/public/blog-images/gallery-best-mattress-stores-tallahassee-florida-1766124239302.png)
![Best Mattress Brands in Tallahassee, Florida [2025 Guide]](https://euwpgvegcebisxlyfgfx.supabase.co/storage/v1/object/public/blog-images/image-1766124394984.png)
![Best Mattress Stores in Lafayette, Louisiana [2025 Guide]](https://euwpgvegcebisxlyfgfx.supabase.co/storage/v1/object/public/blog-images/image-1766081105594.png)