Best Mattress Brands in Evansville, Indiana [2025 Guide]

Quick Brand Comparison

Here's a quick overview of the top mattress brands available in Evansville, helping you narrow down your search based on your specific sleep needs and budget.

Brand	Best For	Price Range	Local Retailers
Sealy	Back sleepers, durability	$$ - Mid-range	Ashley Store, Big Sandy Superstore
Serta	Side sleepers, pressure relief	$$ - Mid-range	Mattress Firm, Bosler's Furniture
Tempur-Pedic	Chronic pain, motion isolation	$$$$ - Luxury	Ashley Store, Furniture Row
Stearns & Foster	Traditional luxury seekers	$$$ - Premium	Big Sandy Superstore, Mattress Firm
Simmons	Hot sleepers, edge support	$$ - Mid-range	Ashley Store, Bosler's Furniture
Purple	Hot sleepers, unique feel	$$$ - Premium	Ashley Store, Furniture Row
Nectar	Side sleepers, value seekers	$$ - Mid-range	Evansville Overstock, Mattress Kingdom
Doctor's Choice	Orthopedic support needs	$$ - Mid-range	Denver Mattress, Furniture Row
Beautyrest	Motion isolation, couples	$$$ - Premium	Ashley Store, Mattress Firm
Nightengale Collection	Budget-conscious buyers	$ - Budget	Mark's Mattress Outlet

Best Mattress Brands Available in Evansville

Evansville residents have access to numerous quality mattress brands across the city's 20+ mattress retailers. From the Lloyd Expressway corridor to Green River Road, you'll find established brands that cater to different sleep positions, health conditions, and budgets.

Sealy

America's bestselling mattress brand, Sealy combines traditional innerspring construction with modern materials in their Posturepedic line. Known for excellent edge support and durability, Sealy mattresses feature targeted support zones that align with your body's natural curves.

Best for: Back sleepers and those needing long-lasting durability
Price Range: $$ - Mid-range ($600-$1,500)
Available locally at: Ashley Store, Big Sandy Superstore, and Furniture Row

Serta

Serta's Perfect Sleeper and iComfort lines address common sleep problems like heat retention and pressure points. Their gel memory foam technology helps regulate temperature while providing contouring support that's particularly beneficial for side sleepers.

Best for: Side sleepers with pressure point sensitivity
Price Range: $$ - Mid-range ($500-$1,400)
Available locally at: Mattress Firm Evansville Pavilion, Bosler's Furniture & Mattress, and Ashley Store

Tempur-Pedic

The original memory foam mattress company, Tempur-Pedic uses proprietary TEMPUR material that responds to body heat and weight for personalized support. Their mattresses excel at motion isolation and pressure relief, making them ideal for couples and those with chronic pain conditions.

Best for: Chronic pain sufferers and couples needing motion isolation
Price Range: $$$$ - Luxury ($2,000-$4,500)
Available locally at: Furniture Row, Big Sandy Superstore, and Ashley Store

Stearns & Foster

This luxury brand handcrafts mattresses using premium materials like cashmere, silk, and high-quality coils. Stearns & Foster combines traditional craftsmanship with modern sleep technology, offering a more opulent sleep experience.

Best for: Traditional luxury seekers who prefer a classic feel
Price Range: $$$ - Premium ($1,500-$3,000)
Available locally at: Big Sandy Superstore, Mattress Firm, and Furniture Row

Simmons

Famous for their Beautyrest Black line, Simmons pioneered pocketed coil technology that provides individualized support and excellent motion isolation. Their mattresses feature advanced cooling technologies and strong edge support.

Best for: Hot sleepers who need temperature regulation and edge support
Price Range: $$ - Mid-range ($700-$1,800)
Available locally at: Ashley Store, Bosler's Furniture & Mattress, and Mattress Firm locations

Purple

Purple's unique gel grid technology creates a distinctive sleep surface that's both supportive and cooling. The grid design allows for excellent airflow while providing targeted pressure relief, making it popular among hot sleepers and those seeking an unconventional feel.

Best for: Hot sleepers seeking unique pressure relief and cooling
Price Range: $$$ - Premium ($1,000-$2,500)
Available locally at: Ashley Store, Furniture Row, and Big Sandy Superstore

Nectar

This direct-to-consumer brand offers memory foam mattresses with extended trial periods and generous warranties. Nectar focuses on providing quality memory foam sleep at accessible prices, with good pressure relief for side sleepers.

Best for: Side sleepers seeking value and extended trial periods
Price Range: $$ - Mid-range ($600-$1,200)
Available locally at: Evansville Overstock Warehouse, Mattress Kingdom, and select retailers

Doctor's Choice

Developed with input from sleep specialists, Doctor's Choice mattresses focus on orthopedic support and spinal alignment. These mattresses use high-density foams and targeted support zones to address specific sleep health concerns.

Best for: Those with orthopedic concerns needing medical-grade support
Price Range: $$ - Mid-range ($800-$1,600)
Available locally at: Denver Mattress and Furniture Row

Beautyrest

Beautyrest's signature pocketed coil system provides individualized support and exceptional motion isolation. Their Black and Platinum lines incorporate advanced materials like memory foam and cooling technologies for enhanced comfort.

Best for: Couples needing motion isolation and individualized support
Price Range: $$$ - Premium ($1,200-$2,800)
Available locally at: Ashley Store, Mattress Firm, and Bosler's Furniture & Mattress

Nightengale Collection

A regional brand offering quality mattresses at budget-friendly prices, Nightengale Collection focuses on providing essential comfort and support without premium pricing. These mattresses offer solid construction and basic comfort features.

Best for: Budget-conscious buyers needing reliable basic comfort
Price Range: $ - Budget ($300-$800)
Available locally at: Mark's Mattress Outlet locations throughout Evansville

Understanding Mattress Types and Sleep Health

Your mattress choice significantly impacts your sleep quality and physical health. Research shows that the right mattress can reduce back pain and improve sleep quality, while the wrong one can exacerbate existing conditions.

Memory Foam for Pressure Relief

Memory foam mattresses excel at contouring to your body's shape, distributing weight evenly and reducing pressure points. This makes them particularly beneficial for side sleepers who experience hip and shoulder pressure. The material's temperature sensitivity allows it to soften where your body is warmest, providing customized support throughout the night.

Hybrid Mattresses for Support and Comfort

Hybrid mattresses combine the pressure relief of foam layers with the support and responsiveness of innerspring coils. According to sleep experts, hybrids work well for combination sleepers who change positions frequently, providing both contouring comfort and responsive support that makes movement easier.

Innerspring for Traditional Sleepers

Traditional innerspring mattresses offer excellent cooling properties and strong edge support. The coil system allows for superior airflow, making them ideal for hot sleepers. Modern innerspring designs feature individually wrapped coils that reduce motion transfer while maintaining the bouncy, responsive feel many sleepers prefer.

Firmness and Sleep Position

Your preferred sleep position should guide your firmness choice. Sleep research indicates that side sleepers typically need softer surfaces (4-6 on a 1-10 scale) to accommodate hip and shoulder curves, while back and stomach sleepers benefit from firmer support (6-8) to maintain spinal alignment. Before making your decision, consider using a mattress size calculator and reviewing our comprehensive buying guide for additional guidance.

Where to Buy These Brands Locally

Evansville offers numerous options for mattress shopping, from large furniture retailers to specialized mattress stores. The city's major shopping corridors along East Lloyd Expressway and Green River Road house most of the area's mattress retailers, making it convenient to comparison shop.

Ashley Store on Green River Road carries the widest selection of premium brands including Sealy, Tempur-Pedic, and Purple. Big Sandy Superstore on East Indiana Street offers competitive pricing across multiple brand lines, while Mattress Firm locations specialize exclusively in sleep products with knowledgeable staff and frequent promotions. For budget-conscious shoppers, Mark's Mattress Outlet provides quality options at lower price points.

When visiting these retailers, bring our mattress buying checklist to ensure you evaluate all important factors. Most local stores offer sleep trials and delivery services, so don't hesitate to ask about these options during your visit.

Prefer Shopping Online?

If you'd rather skip the store visits, Sleepology offers a compelling alternative. They carry many premium mattress brands with commission-free pricing (no sales commissions added to prices), a "double-the-difference" price match guarantee, and their Price Predictor™ tool ensures you're getting the best deal. It's a transparent, no-pressure shopping experience with white-glove delivery. Use code DELIVERY for free delivery: Shop Sleepology.