Best Mattress Stores in Brooklyn, New York [2026 Guide]

Quick Mattress Store Comparisons

Top Mattress Stores in Brooklyn

Raymour & Flanigan Furniture and Mattress Store

This family-owned chain brings serious credibility to Brooklyn's mattress scene with knowledgeable staff and premium brands. They've been in business for decades and it shows in their customer service approach.

Queens typically start around $699 for quality models, with luxury options reaching $2000+. They carry Tempur-Pedic, Beautyrest Black, and their exclusive R&F brand mattresses.

Best for: Quality seekers, couples needing different firmness levels, warranty coverage
Contact: Multiple locations
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 646-964-0648

Mattress Firm Atlantic Ctr

As the nation's largest mattress retailer, Mattress Firm brings the biggest selection to Brooklyn. Their Atlantic Center location is convenient for those near Downtown Brooklyn and offers their signature 120-night sleep trial.

Queens range from $399 for basic models up to $3000+ for luxury brands. They stock Purple, Casper, Tempur-Pedic, Serta, and nearly every major mattress brand available.

Best for: Comparison shopping, trying multiple brands, sleep trials
Contact: Multiple locations
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 718-622-1318

Furniture To Go

This Flatbush Avenue gem offers personalized service that's hard to find at larger chains. The owners know their community and stock mattresses that work well for Brooklyn apartments and budgets.

Queens start around $450 with kings reaching $899 for mid-range options. They focus on reliable brands like Sealy Posturepedic and offer flexible payment plans for local customers.

Best for: Local community feel, flexible payment options, apartment-friendly sizes
Contact: 2364 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11234
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 718-252-2005

Ashley Store

Ashley brings their nationwide furniture expertise to Brooklyn with a solid mattress selection alongside complete bedroom sets. They're particularly good if you want to coordinate your mattress purchase with a new bed frame or dresser.

Queens start around $379 for their basic models, with premium options reaching $1500. Their Ashley-Sleep brand offers good value, plus they carry Sealy and other national brands.

Best for: Complete bedroom makeovers, coordinated furniture sets, contemporary styles
Contact: Multiple locations
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 732-548-1200

New Lots Furniture

Located in East New York, this neighborhood store has been serving Brooklyn families for years with honest pricing and straightforward service. They understand the local market and stock mattresses that work for Brooklyn living.

Queens typically range from $349 to $899, focusing on the sweet spot most Brooklyn shoppers need. They carry dependable brands and offer delivery throughout Brooklyn.

Best for: East Brooklyn residents, straightforward shopping, community-focused service
Contact: 460 New Lots Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11207
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 718-257-6644

Delivery Considerations

Brooklyn mattress delivery comes with unique challenges that Manhattan shoppers don't always face. Most stores offer delivery windows between 8am-6pm, but the reality of Brooklyn traffic means you might want to take the later slots when possible. Delivery fees typically range from $79-$149, though many stores waive fees on purchases over $699.

Here's what Brooklyn shoppers need to know: older apartment buildings without elevators cost extra (usually $50-100 per flight), parking restrictions in neighborhoods like Park Slope and Brooklyn Heights can cause delays, and weekend delivery slots fill up fast. Always ask about haul-away service for your old mattress - it usually costs $25-50 but saves you the headache of disposal in Brooklyn.

White glove delivery and setup is worth considering if you're buying a heavy memory foam or hybrid mattress. Most stores charge $99-149 for this service, but it includes unpacking, setup, and old mattress removal. Check our mattress buying checklist before scheduling delivery to ensure you're prepared.

Mattress Buying Guide

Understanding Firmness Levels

Firmness preference is personal, but Brooklyn's diverse housing stock means your current mattress might not reflect your true preference. If you're sleeping on a hand-me-down or old mattress in your current apartment, don't base your firmness choice on that experience.

Medium-firm works for most people and sleeping positions, while side sleepers often prefer medium to medium-soft for better hip and shoulder pressure relief. Back and stomach sleepers typically need medium-firm to firm support. Brooklyn stores usually let you test mattresses for at least 10-15 minutes, which isn't enough to truly know but gives you a baseline.

Most quality mattresses need 30-90 days to break in, so that "just right" feel in the showroom might change. That's why sleep trials are crucial - stores like Mattress Firm offer 120 nights to decide.

Size Selection Strategy

Brooklyn apartments demand smart size choices. That king size might look perfect in the suburban showroom, but measure your bedroom first - you need at least 24 inches of walking space around the bed. Many Brooklyn bedrooms work better with queens, which provide good space for couples without overwhelming the room.

Consider your building's stairways and elevator dimensions too. Standard door frames are 32 inches wide, but older Brooklyn buildings might be narrower. Most mattresses compress for delivery, but it's worth checking with your store about any size restrictions for your specific address.

Full-size mattresses work well for studio apartments or smaller bedrooms, while twin XL is perfect for younger adults who want more length than a standard twin. Use our mattress size guide to compare dimensions and room requirements before heading to the store.

Budget Planning

Brooklyn mattress shopping requires realistic budgeting beyond just the mattress price. A quality queen mattress typically runs $600-1200, but factor in delivery ($79-149), potential setup fees ($99-149), and old mattress disposal ($25-50). Sales tax in Brooklyn adds about 8.25% to your total.

The good news is Brooklyn stores compete aggressively on price. Bob's and Ashley often run sales with queens under $500, while Raymour & Flanigan and Mattress Firm offer better financing options for higher-end purchases. Many stores offer 0% financing for 12-48 months with approved credit.

Don't forget accessories - Brooklyn's older buildings often need mattress protectors ($50-100) due to potential radiator leaks or building issues. A basic bed frame runs $100-300 if you need one. Our mattress budget calculator helps you plan for the total investment.

Prefer Shopping Online?

If Brooklyn's traffic and limited parking make store visits challenging, Sleepology offers a compelling online alternative with benefits you won't find at traditional mattress stores. Their commission-free pricing means no sales commissions are added to your mattress cost, and their "double-the-difference" price match guarantee ensures you get the best deal available.

What makes Sleepology particularly appealing for Brooklyn shoppers is their Price Predictor™ tool that ensures optimal pricing timing, plus they carry premium mattress brands all in one place without high-pressure salespeople. Their transparent, education-focused approach gives you clean, no-haggle pricing with in-home white glove delivery. Brooklyn residents can get free delivery using code DELIVERY at checkout, making it a convenient option for busy city life.