Things we like about them
Since 1886
Built in Jamestown, NY. Their history
Pullan family
Family owned and operated
Made in their factory
Their own factory in Jamestown, NY. Made in Jamestown
8 stores
Western New York and Northwest Pennsylvania
30-night guarantee
30 Night Comfort Guarantee
10-year warranty
Their own delivery team
Free local delivery and setup over $599 before tax, inside their service area. Delivery and setup
Financing
Available
Custom sizes
Antique beds, boats, RVs and campers. Custom sizes
What makes them different
They make the mattress and sell it in their own stores, so there is no wholesale markup. They claim up to 50% off compared to other retailers.
Between day 7 and day 30, they will open the mattress and change the upholstery layers inside to adjust the feel. One time per customer, inside the delivery area, with a pickup and redelivery fee, or free if the customer brings it to the factory. Almost no retailer in the country can do this.
They build non-standard sizes for antique beds, boats, RVs and campers. Custom size mattresses
Where to buy
Find a storeEight stores across New York and Pennsylvania.
135 E Fairmount Ave, Lakewood, NY 14750
Mon–Thu 10AM-5PM, Fri 10AM-7PM, Sat 10AM-4PM, Sun Closed
10 W Main St, Fredonia, NY 14063
Mon–Wed 10AM-5PM, Thu–Fri 10AM-7PM, Sat 10AM-4PM, Sun Closed
948 Union Rd, West Seneca, NY 14224
Mon–Fri 10AM-7PM, Sat 10AM-5PM, Sun Closed
6412 S Transit Rd, Lockport, NY 14094
Mon 10AM-8PM, Tue–Fri 10AM-6PM, Sat 10AM-5PM, Sun Closed
3145 W Henrietta Rd, Rochester, NY 14623
Mon 10AM-8PM, Tue–Fri 10AM-6PM, Sat 10AM-5PM, Sun Closed
1946 W 8th St, Erie, PA 16505
Mon 10AM-7PM, Tue–Fri 10AM-6PM, Sat 10AM-5PM, Sun Closed
312 2nd Ave, Warren, PA 16365
Mon–Thu 10AM-5PM, Fri 10AM-6PM, Sat 10AM-4PM, Sun Closed
A good fit for shoppers who want a mattress made locally, want to lie on it before buying, want a two-sided flippable bed, need a custom size, or want the feel adjusted after buying.
Not a fit for shoppers outside Western New York and Northwest PA, shoppers who want to buy online and have it shipped, and shoppers who want to comparison shop national brand names in the same store.
Where are Jamestown Mattress mattresses made?
Jamestown Mattress mattresses are made at their own factory in Jamestown, NY. The company has built mattresses in Western New York since 1886.
Is there a trial period?
Jamestown Mattress offers a 30 Night Comfort Guarantee. Between day 7 and day 30, their 30 Day Comfort Adjustment Program will open the mattress and change the upholstery layers inside to adjust the feel. That adjustment is one time per customer, inside the delivery area, with a pickup and redelivery fee, or free if the customer brings the mattress to the factory.
What is the warranty?
Jamestown Mattress mattresses come with a 10-year limited warranty.
Do they deliver?
Yes. Free local delivery and setup are included on orders over $599 before tax, inside their service area, and the mattress is delivered by their own team.
Do they make custom sizes?
Yes. Jamestown Mattress builds non-standard sizes for antique beds, boats, RVs and campers.
How many stores are there?
Jamestown Mattress has 8 stores across Western New York and Northwest Pennsylvania.
Jamestown Mattress is an advertising partner of WhereToBuyAMattress.com. Partners do not pay for placement in our editorial rankings.