Mattress Buying Checklist
Simple, step-by-step checklist that helps you choose where to buy online or in-store with confidence.
Print this mattress buying checklist or keep it on your phone. Use it to compare retailers, confirm policies, check delivery and setup, and choose the best place to buy a mattress.
How to Use This Mattress Shopping Checklist
This tool compares retailers, not models. It works as an online mattress shopping checklist and an in-store mattress shopping checklist.
Skim each step. Open two retailers from our directory. Fill in the tables as you go. This mattress store checklist keeps the focus on where to buy a mattress.
Tip: Save screenshots or print the printable mattress buying checklist. It speeds up side-by-side comparisons.
Quick start
- Open two retailer pages from the directory
- Complete each table below as you browse
- Decide using the Total Value worksheet
Step 1 — Define Your Sleep Profile and Constraints
Clarify needs first. It makes every comparison fair.
Primary sleep position: side, back, stomach, or combo
Preferred feel: plush, medium, or firm
Pain points: shoulder, hip, lower back; note height and weight
Room constraints: stairs, tight corners, elevator access
Budget range and target delivery window
Use this info to filter stores by brand, technology, delivery, and setup.
Step 2 — Pick Your Shopping Path
Online path
Shortlist two or three reputable sites with clear policies and delivery.
In-store path
Shortlist two nearby stores that carry your target technologies.
Step 3 — Build a Retailer Shortlist
Use our directory to find mattress stores near you and trusted online retailers.
Pick at least two retailers that carry your target materials and brands
Verify contact methods: phone, chat, email
Scan recent, verified reviews for delivery and resolution speed
Bookmark each store page for policy and service details
Step 4 — Policy and Warranty Checklist
Confirm these details before you buy. This is your mattress return policy checklist.
| Area | What to Confirm | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Trial and Comfort Exchange | Length, required protector, minimum nights | |
| Returns | Return shipping cost, restocking fees, return window | |
| Exchanges | Exchange fees, delivery logistics, timelines | |
| Warranty | Coverage years, sag depth, claim process | |
| Price Protection | Low price guarantees or adjustments |
Step 5 — Delivery, Setup, and Removal
Turn fees into one clear number with this mattress delivery checklist.
| Service | Retailer A | Retailer B | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Delivery window (days) | |||
| White glove setup (cost) | |||
| Old mattress removal (cost) | |||
| Stairs or heavy surcharges | |||
| Estimated delivery date |
Tip: convert services to a single total number for apples-to-apples.
Step 6 — Technology Fit (Materials and Feel)
Match your sleep profile to mattress materials: innerspring, memory foam, hybrid, latex. If you need elevation, consider an adjustable base.
Open our technologies guide, then filter stores that carry the right materials. This keeps the focus on where to buy a mattress.
Step 7 — Comfort Evaluation Method
In-store
- Test 5–10 minutes in your normal position
- Capture spec labels or request spec sheets
Online
- Rely on the at-home trial
- Set a calendar reminder two weeks before the trial ends
Step 8 — Total Value Worksheet
Turn each quote into an apples-to-apples number.
| Line Item | Retailer A | Retailer B | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sticker price | |||
| Sales discount or promo | |||
| Delivery, setup, removal | |||
| Accessories: pillows, protector, base | |||
| Financing cost (if any) | |||
| Estimated return or exchange exposure | |||
| Final total (estimate) |
Step 9 — Decide and Save Your Paperwork
Bonus — Best Time to Buy a Mattress
Holiday events often bring broader brand participation and stronger bundles than everyday promos. If your timing is flexible, compare during major weekends. If you need a bed now, use the checklist and pick the best total value today.
You can find the most up-to-date promotions on each store page within our site.
FAQ — Mattress Buying Checklist
Do I use this checklist online or in a store?
What should I ask at a mattress store?
How do I compare two online retailers?
Where is the cheapest place to buy a mattress?
Can I return a mattress if I do not like it?
Should I buy a mattress online or in store?
You Are Ready — Choose Where to Buy with Confidence
You have a clear plan and the right tools. Compare trusted retailers, confirm policies and services, and pick the path that fits your style and timeline.
Need options now? Use our directory to find mattress stores near you and trusted online retailers.