Best Mattress Brands in New Castle, Indiana [2026 Guide]

Best Mattress Brands in New Castle, Indiana [2026 Guide]

Shopping for a mattress in New Castle, Indiana means you have real options - and knowing which brands are actually available at local stores can save you a lot of time and second-guessing. This guide covers the 10 mattress brands you can find right here in town, what makes each one worth considering for your sleep health, and exactly where to go to try them out.

Whether you sleep on your side, deal with back pain, or just need a new bed that won't break the budget, the right mattress is out there. Use our comprehensive mattress buying guide alongside this post to make a well-informed decision before you walk through any store door.

Quick Brand Comparison

Best Mattress Brands Available in New Castle

10 Inch Chime Elite 2.0

The 10 Inch Chime Elite 2.0 is an Ashley-manufactured memory foam mattress that punches above its price point. It features gel-infused foam designed to pull heat away from the body during sleep, making it a reasonable pick for people who tend to sleep warm but don't want to pay luxury prices. At 10 inches, it works well on most standard bed frames and platform bases without the bulk of a taller mattress.

Best for: Back sleepers and budget shoppers who want basic cooling and memory foam comfort
Price Range: $ - Budget
Available locally at: Myers Furniture & Appliances at 2121 S Memorial Dr, New Castle, IN 47362

1100 Series

The 1100 Series is a Beautyrest innerspring mattress line built around a traditional pocketed coil system. Pocketed coils move independently from one another, which helps reduce motion transfer - useful if you share a bed with a restless partner. The design offers a firmer, more classic feel that many back and stomach sleepers prefer over the sinking sensation of memory foam.

Best for: Combination sleepers and those who prefer a traditional spring feel with low motion transfer
Price Range: $$ - Mid-range
Available locally at: Myers Furniture & Appliances at 2121 S Memorial Dr, New Castle, IN 47362

12 Inch Chime Elite 2.0

The 12 Inch Chime Elite 2.0 is the taller sibling of the 10 Inch model, adding extra foam layers for more contouring and pressure relief. Those extra two inches make a meaningful difference for side sleepers, who need their shoulders and hips to sink in slightly so the spine stays level. Research into side sleeper needs consistently points to pressure relief at the shoulder and hip as the top priority when choosing a mattress.

Best for: Side sleepers and anyone dealing with shoulder or hip discomfort
Price Range: $ to $$ - Budget to Mid-range
Available locally at: Myers Furniture & Appliances at 2121 S Memorial Dr, New Castle, IN 47362

American

American mattresses at American Rental Home Furnishings give New Castle shoppers a rent-to-own path to a quality bed without the full upfront cost. This can be a practical solution for people in a transitional living situation, first-time renters, or anyone who needs a good mattress now and wants to spread payments over time. The selection tends toward mid-range models with a straightforward comfort profile.

Best for: Shoppers who prefer flexible payment options or rent-to-own arrangements
Price Range: $$ - Mid-range
Available locally at: American Rental Home Furnishings at 427 S Memorial Dr, New Castle, IN 47362

Ashley Furniture

Ashley Furniture is one of the most widely recognized furniture and mattress brands in the country, and for good reason - they offer a wide price spectrum from entry-level foam beds to more advanced hybrid models. At Myers Furniture & Appliances in New Castle, the Ashley mattress selection gives shoppers a chance to compare multiple comfort levels and constructions in one visit. Their beds are designed with accessible pricing in mind, making sleep health improvements attainable for most budgets.

Best for: Value-conscious shoppers who want to compare several mattress types in one place
Price Range: $ to $$$ - Wide range across multiple models
Available locally at: Myers Furniture & Appliances at 2121 S Memorial Dr, New Castle, IN 47362

Gray

The Gray mattress line at Myers Furniture & Appliances features a clean, minimalist design aesthetic alongside straightforward foam comfort. It's a solid choice for shoppers who want a modern-looking bed that doesn't overcomplicate the buying process. The foam construction provides decent contouring without the deep sinking feel of higher-density memory foam models.

Best for: Shoppers who prefer foam comfort with a contemporary look and uncomplicated feature set
Price Range: $$ - Mid-range
Available locally at: Myers Furniture & Appliances at 2121 S Memorial Dr, New Castle, IN 47362

Hybrid 1200

The Hybrid 1200 combines pocketed coils with foam comfort layers, giving you the responsiveness of a spring mattress and the contouring of foam in one construction. This tends to work particularly well for combination sleepers who switch positions during the night, because the coils make it easier to move around without feeling stuck. Back support is generally better in hybrids than in all-foam beds because the coil system provides a firmer foundation underneath the comfort layers.

Best for: Combination sleepers and back sleepers who want both support and some foam contouring
Price Range: $$ - Mid-range
Available locally at: Myers Furniture & Appliances at 2121 S Memorial Dr, New Castle, IN 47362

Comfort Plus

Comfort Plus models are built with added cushioning layers designed to take pressure off the shoulders, hips, and lower back - areas that take the most stress in side sleepers. If you wake up with a numb arm or a sore hip, a mattress with more pressure relief in the upper comfort layers is usually part of the answer. The Comfort Plus line at Myers Furniture aims to hit that sweet spot between plush and supportive.

Best for: Side sleepers and people who experience morning soreness at pressure points
Price Range: $$ - Mid-range
Available locally at: Myers Furniture & Appliances at 2121 S Memorial Dr, New Castle, IN 47362

Cloverlane

Cloverlane is a step up in the lineup, offering better materials and more attention to spinal alignment. Good spinal alignment during sleep is more than a comfort preference - spinal health research shows that how the spine is positioned overnight has a direct effect on daytime pain and long-term musculoskeletal health. Cloverlane mattresses are designed to support the natural curve of the spine for back sleepers and keep the spine level for side sleepers.

Best for: Back pain sufferers and sleepers who prioritize spinal alignment over everything else
Price Range: $$$ - Mid to Luxury
Available locally at: Myers Furniture & Appliances at 2121 S Memorial Dr, New Castle, IN 47362

Beautyrest

Beautyrest is a heritage brand with decades of pocketed coil innovation behind it. Their mattresses are known for individually wrapped coils that reduce motion transfer and promote airflow through the sleep surface, which is a real benefit for anyone who sleeps hot. At American Rental Home Furnishings in New Castle, Beautyrest is available through flexible purchase or rent-to-own arrangements, making the brand more accessible than its reputation might suggest.

Best for: Hot sleepers, couples with different sleep schedules, and anyone who wants pocketed coil support with name-brand confidence
Price Range: $$ to $$$ - Mid to Luxury
Available locally at: American Rental Home Furnishings at 427 S Memorial Dr, New Castle, IN 47362

Understanding Mattress Types and Sleep Health

Memory Foam for Pressure Relief

Memory foam mattresses conform to the shape of your body, which distributes weight more evenly across the sleep surface. For side sleepers especially, this contouring effect reduces the pressure that builds up at the shoulder and hip when those points press into a firmer surface. Less pressure means fewer interruptions during the night and less morning stiffness. The 10 Inch and 12 Inch Chime Elite 2.0 models are both good examples of memory foam beds available right here in New Castle. Side sleeper guidance from Healthline points to foam that allows at least 2-3 inches of contouring depth as a key factor for waking up without a sore shoulder.

Hybrid Mattresses for Support and Comfort

Hybrid mattresses layer foam or latex comfort materials on top of a pocketed coil support core. The coils give you lift and responsiveness - you don't feel like you're sinking into the bed - while the foam layers on top take care of cushioning and pressure points. This combination makes hybrids a good fit for people who like the feel of a traditional spring mattress but want some of the body-contouring benefits of foam. The Hybrid 1200 at Myers Furniture represents this category locally. Research published in a peer-reviewed medical journal suggests that medium-firm mattresses - the kind that hybrids often fall into - are associated with better outcomes for people dealing with chronic back discomfort.

Innerspring for Traditional Sleepers

Innerspring mattresses have been around the longest, and they still have a loyal following for good reasons. The coil-based construction allows air to move through the mattress more freely than foam, keeping the sleep surface cooler over the course of the night. Stomach sleepers and back sleepers often do better on innerspring or firmer hybrid beds because those constructions keep the hips from sinking too deeply, which can create a bowed spine position. The 1100 Series at Myers Furniture is the clearest example of a traditional innerspring construction available locally in New Castle.

Firmness and Sleep Position

Firmness is not a matter of personal taste alone - it has a direct effect on spinal alignment while you sleep. Side sleepers generally need something softer (around a 3-5 on a 10-point firmness scale) to allow the shoulder and hip to sink in so the spine stays straight. Back sleepers do best in the medium range (5-7). Stomach sleepers usually need firmer support (7-9) to prevent the lower back from arching uncomfortably. Getting firmness wrong is one of the most common reasons people are unhappy with a new mattress. Use our mattress buying checklist to match your sleep position to the right firmness level before you shop, and check our size guide to make sure you're also buying the right dimensions for your room.

Where to Buy These Brands Locally

New Castle has two key local spots for mattress shopping, and each one serves a slightly different type of buyer.

Myers Furniture & Appliances at 2121 S Memorial Dr carries the widest selection of the two, stocking eight of the ten brands featured in this guide. If you want to walk in and compare multiple mattress types - foam, hybrid, innerspring - in a single trip, this is your best starting point in New Castle. The range of price points there also means you're not locked into one budget tier.

American Rental Home Furnishings at 427 S Memorial Dr is the place to go if you want access to the American and Beautyrest brands locally, particularly if a rent-to-own arrangement fits your financial situation better than a full purchase. It's worth calling ahead to confirm current availability and any promotions before making the drive.

Before visiting either store, download our mattress buying checklist and review the full buying guide so you know what questions to ask and what to look for when you're lying on the showroom floor.

Prefer Shopping Online?

If you'd rather skip the store visits, Sleepology offers a compelling alternative. They carry many premium mattress brands with commission-free pricing (no sales commissions added to prices), a "double-the-difference" price match guarantee, and their Price Predictor tool ensures you're getting the best deal. It's a transparent, no-pressure shopping experience with white-glove delivery. Use code DELIVERY for free delivery: Shop Sleepology.