Best Mattress Stores in Greeley, Colorado [2026 Guide]

Quick Mattress Store Comparisons

Here's a quick overview of Greeley's mattress retailers to help you narrow down your options before making the trip across town.

Top Mattress Stores in Greeley

Denver Mattress

Located on Centerplace Drive, Denver Mattress has built a solid reputation for factory-direct pricing without the middleman markup. They manufacture many of their own mattresses, which means better prices and quality control for Greeley shoppers.

You'll find queen mattresses starting around $400, with their premium models reaching $1,200. Their Doctor's Choice and Rest Easy lines offer good value for memory foam and hybrid options.

Best for: Budget-conscious buyers who want quality without breaking the bank
Contact: 4206 Centerplace Dr #718, Greeley, CO 80634
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 970-336-9999

Mattress Firm Greeley

This national chain location on 35th Avenue offers the widest brand selection in Greeley. You'll find everything from Sealy and Serta to Purple and Tempur-Pedic under one roof.

Queens typically start around $500 and can reach $3,000+ for premium models. They run frequent sales events and offer a 90-night sleep trial on most purchases.

Best for: Shoppers who want to test multiple major brands in one location
Contact: 2839 35th Ave, Greeley, CO 80634
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 970-330-2445

Appliance Factory

This local business combines appliance and mattress sales, making it a convenient option if you're outfitting a new home or apartment. Their staff knows the area well and provides honest, no-pressure guidance.

Mattress prices are competitive with queens starting around $350. They focus on value brands and often have floor models at significant discounts.

Best for: One-stop shopping for appliances and mattresses
Contact: 2780 8th Ave #1, Greeley, CO 80631
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 970-304-6880

America's Mattress Greeley

Situated in the Centerplace shopping area, this store focuses on complete sleep solutions beyond just mattresses. They carry adjustable bases, pillows, and bedding accessories to create your ideal sleep environment.

Queen mattresses range from $450 to $1,800, with good selection in memory foam and hybrid categories. Their sleep specialists take time to understand your specific needs.

Best for: Customers wanting comprehensive sleep solutions and accessories
Contact: 4330 Centerplace Dr #624, Greeley, CO 80634
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 970-978-4105

Ben's Furniture Galleries

A Greeley institution on West 10th Street, Ben's has been serving the community for decades. While primarily a furniture store, they maintain a solid mattress selection and can coordinate delivery with your bedroom furniture purchase.

Their mattress prices range from $400 to $2,000 for queens, with established relationships with quality manufacturers. The advantage here is coordinating your entire bedroom setup.

Best for: Customers furnishing entire bedrooms or wanting established local service
Contact: 2816 W 10th St, Greeley, CO 80634
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 970-352-0146

Mattress Kingdom

This locally-focused retailer on 8th Avenue prides itself on personalized service and competitive pricing. They work hard to match prices and provide honest recommendations based on your sleep preferences and budget.

Queens start around $300 for basic models, reaching $1,500 for premium options. They often have special deals for local residents and first responders.

Best for: Shoppers wanting personalized attention and local business support
Contact: 2780 8th Ave #4, Greeley, CO 80631
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 970-909-2228

Delivery Considerations

Most Greeley mattress stores offer delivery throughout Weld County, but policies vary significantly. Denver Mattress and Mattress Firm typically charge $100-150 for delivery and setup, while local stores like Ben's Furniture and Mattress Kingdom often include free delivery on purchases over $500.

Delivery windows usually span 2-4 hours, and many stores offer weekend delivery for busy professionals. If you're replacing an old mattress, ask about haul-away services upfront (usually $50-75 extra). Some stores like America's Mattress include basic setup, while others charge $25-50 for this service. Plan for delivery 3-7 days after purchase, though some floor models may be available for same-day pickup.

Before scheduling delivery, measure your doorways and stairwells. Greeley's older homes near downtown sometimes have narrow staircases that require split king mattresses instead of California kings. Use our mattress size guide to ensure proper fit before ordering.

Mattress Buying Guide

Understanding Firmness Levels

Firmness preferences vary widely, and what feels firm to one person might feel soft to another. Most manufacturers use a 1-10 scale, with 1 being very soft and 10 being very firm. Side sleepers typically prefer 4-6 (medium-soft to medium), while back sleepers usually like 5-7 (medium to medium-firm), and stomach sleepers often need 7-9 (medium-firm to firm).

When testing mattresses in Greeley stores, spend at least 10-15 minutes in your normal sleep position. Don't be swayed by initial comfort – focus on proper spinal alignment and pressure point relief. Your hips and shoulders should sink slightly while maintaining support for your lower back.

Keep in mind that new mattresses often feel different than floor models that have been tested by hundreds of customers. Quality mattresses typically have a break-in period of 2-4 weeks as materials conform to your body.

Size Selection Strategy

Size selection goes beyond just room dimensions. Consider your height, sleep partner, pets, and future needs. A queen mattress (60" x 80") works for most couples, but if either partner is over 6'2" or you have restless sleepers, consider a king (76" x 80") or California king (72" x 84").

For Greeley's smaller apartments and condos near UNC, a full mattress (54" x 75") might be the largest practical option. However, if you're planning to stay long-term, investing in a queen provides much better sleep quality. Twin XL mattresses work well for college students and growing teenagers.

Measure your room carefully, leaving at least 24 inches of walking space on the side you get out of bed most often. Our mattress calculator can help determine the ideal size for your space and needs.

Budget Planning

Quality mattresses represent a significant investment, but you don't need to spend a fortune for good sleep. In Greeley's market, expect to pay $400-800 for a decent queen mattress that will last 6-8 years. Premium models ($900-2000) typically offer better materials, longer warranties, and 8-12 year lifespans.

Factor in additional costs like delivery ($50-150), mattress protectors ($50-100), and potentially new pillows ($25-100 each) or box springs ($100-300). Many stores offer package deals that can save money on these accessories.

Timing your purchase around major sales events (Memorial Day, Labor Day, Black Friday) can yield 20-50% savings. However, don't let sales pressure override comfort and quality considerations. Use our mattress buying checklist to stay focused on your actual needs.

Prefer Shopping Online?

While testing mattresses in person has advantages, online shopping offers convenience and often better prices. Sleepology stands out as a legitimate at-home option that eliminates commission-driven sales pressure. Their commission-free pricing means you're not paying extra to cover salespeople's commissions, and their "double-the-difference" price match guarantee ensures competitive pricing.

What sets Sleepology apart is their Price Predictor™ tool and educational approach. Instead of high-pressure tactics, they focus on helping you understand your sleep needs and find the right mattress accordingly. They carry premium brands all in one place with transparent, no-haggle pricing. Plus, they offer in-home white glove delivery to Greeley, and you can get free delivery with code DELIVERY at checkout.