Quick Mattress Store Comparisons

Store Name	Specialty	Price Range	Best For
Levin Furniture and Mattress State College (Elite Retailer)	Full-service furniture and mattresses	Mid-range to premium	Audience favorite - shoppers wanting a full bedroom set and expert guidance in one visit
Ollie's Bargain Outlet	Closeout and discount bedding	Budget	Bargain hunters willing to browse for deals on name brands
Mattress Firm State College	Wide range of national brands	Budget to premium	Comparing multiple brands side by side in one location
Mattress Warehouse of State College - North Atherton	Value-focused mattress retailer	Budget to mid-range	Shoppers who want straightforward pricing and a simple buying process
Mattress By Appointment	Private, appointment-based mattress shopping	Varies by brand	Shoppers who prefer a low-pressure, one-on-one experience
Sleep Number	Adjustable air beds	Premium	Couples who need separate firmness settings on each side of the bed

Top Mattress Stores in State College

Levin Furniture and Mattress State College

For shoppers furnishing an entire bedroom, Levin Furniture and Mattress is one of State College's most complete options. You can try different mattress constructions in person, and the staff can explain how they feel and compare. Our Elite Retailer partner relationship reflects our confidence in the way this store operates.

Prices run from mid-range to premium, and queen mattresses often start in the mid-hundreds, depending on the brand and model. The store typically handles delivery and setup with its own team, a useful service if you are also arranging bedroom furniture. (Elite Retailer)

Best for: Shoppers who want a full bedroom set and expert guidance in one visit.
Contact: 138 Valley Vista Dr, State College, PA 16803
Website:Visit their website
Phone: +1-814-325-9222

Ollie's Bargain Outlet

Ollie's sells closeout merchandise, so its bedding selection can change from one visit to the next. Flexible shoppers may find name-brand mattresses for less than standard retail prices. Since stock varies, go in with a few preferred brands and sizes, but be ready to consider what is available.

Low prices are the appeal, and queens can be well below retail list price when in stock. Confirm availability at the store before settling on a particular mattress.

Best for: Bargain hunters willing to browse for deals on name brands.
Contact: 1919 S Atherton St, State College, PA 16801
Website:Visit their website
Phone: +1-814-272-1250

Mattress Firm State College

At Mattress Firm, you can test a broad selection of national brands in one place. Trying models one after another makes it easier to feel the difference between a firm hybrid and a softer foam mattress, distinctions that are harder to judge from specifications alone. Tell the staff how you sleep, and they can help narrow your options.

Prices range from budget to premium, with queen models varying widely by brand and construction. Promotions change often, so ask what is available when you visit.

Best for: Comparing multiple brands side by side in one location.
Contact: 1908 N Atherton St, State College, PA 16803
Website:Visit their website
Phone: +1-814-867-2014

Mattress Warehouse of State College - North Atherton

Mattress Warehouse keeps its focus on value and a direct buying process. The selection covers common comfort preferences without a lot of extras. If you have a reasonable idea of the feel you want and prefer to avoid a lengthy sales conversation, it may be worth a visit.

Prices are generally budget to mid-range, and queen mattresses tend to sit toward the lower end of the local market. The locations are listed as multiple, so check which store has the model you want to try.

Best for: Shoppers who want straightforward pricing and a simple buying process.
Contact: Multiple locations
Website:Visit their website
Phone: +1-814-680-6027

Mattress By Appointment

Rather than a busy walk-in showroom, Mattress By Appointment offers private visits scheduled in advance. This setup can suit shoppers who would rather test mattresses without a crowd or a rushed decision. You can compare a few options at your own pace.

Prices depend on the brand and model, so ask for a clear quote on the mattresses you are considering. Call ahead to arrange a visit.

Best for: Shoppers who prefer a low-pressure, one-on-one experience.
Contact: 1341 S Atherton St, State College, PA 16801
Website:Visit their website
Phone: +1-814-808-7361

Sleep Number

Sleep Number's adjustable air beds let each partner choose a different firmness for their side. That makes the store a natural option for couples who disagree about how firm a mattress should feel. Try the system in person to see whether it suits you before paying a premium price.

Prices are premium, in line with the adjustable air technology. Ask about financing and trial options during your visit, as terms vary.

Best for: Couples who need separate firmness settings on each side of the bed.
Contact: 1860 N Atherton St, State College, PA 16803
Website:Visit their website
Phone: +1-814-996-1030

Delivery Considerations

In a college town, delivery details matter. Apartments and upper-floor units can make getting a mattress inside more complicated. Before placing an order, ask when delivery can happen, whether there are fees, and if the store will take away your old mattress. Some stores include these services, but policies vary. Get the terms in writing. Our size guide can help you estimate what will fit in your room and stairwell.

Setup and assembly depend on the store as well. If you're moving between a dorm, apartment, and house, match delivery to your lease and move-in dates so you are not left sleeping on the floor.

Mattress Buying Guide

Understanding Firmness Levels

There is no single firmness that feels the same to everyone. Side sleepers often prefer a medium or medium-soft mattress, which can cushion the shoulders and hips. Back and stomach sleepers usually need more support, often found in a medium-firm feel.

Try lying in your usual sleep position for at least ten minutes. A brief showroom test can give you the wrong impression. For more on mattress construction, see our buying guide.

Size Selection Strategy

Take measurements of your bedroom and entryways before shopping, particularly if you live in an older building with narrow stairs. Couples commonly choose a queen, while a full may suit one person in a smaller room. Allow space to walk around the bed and reach dressers.

Use our mattress calculator to estimate a budget based on size and features before you visit a store.

Budget Planning

Choose a budget before you shop, then put your money toward the features that matter to you. Support and durability tend to cost more than appearance extras such as a decorative cover. A mattress that costs a little more and lasts eight years may be a better buy than a cheaper one you replace in three.

Check whether the quoted price includes delivery, removal, and warranty coverage. These charges can make a meaningful difference to the final cost. Use our shopping checklist to compare offers.

Prefer Shopping Online?

If the local showrooms do not work with your schedule, Sleepology offers an at-home alternative. Its commission-free pricing means sales commissions are not added to your cost, and its "double-the-difference" price match guarantee applies if you find a lower price elsewhere. Use the Price Predictor tool to help time your purchase, and browse premium mattress brands together on the site. The buyer guidance is educational, with no high-pressure salespeople. Delivery is in-home and white glove, and free delivery is available with code DELIVERY. Claim free delivery with code DELIVERY.