Best Mattress Brands in Olean, New York [2026 Guide]

Best Mattress Brands in Olean, New York [2026 Guide]

Shopping for a new mattress in Olean means you have real options - more than most people realize. From big-name brands at Raymour & Flanigan on W State St to specialty selections at Mattress Xtreme on Olean-Portville Rd, the local market here covers everything from budget-friendly picks to luxury sleep systems. This guide covers the 10 best mattress brands available right now in Olean, where to find each one locally, and what the sleep research actually says about matching a mattress to your body and sleep style.

Before you head out to any store, it's worth spending two minutes with our mattress size guide and buying checklist so you walk in knowing exactly what you need.

Quick Brand Comparison

Best Mattress Brands Available in Olean

Sealy

Sealy is one of the most widely carried mattress brands in Olean, and for good reason. Their lineup spans innerspring, memory foam, and hybrid designs, with the Posturepedic series being a long-standing choice for people who need firmer support under their hips and lower back. Prices generally run from the mid-hundreds into the low thousands depending on the model, making them accessible across a range of budgets.

Best for: Back and stomach sleepers who want solid spinal support, plus couples with different firmness preferences
Price Range: $$ - $$$ (Mid-range to upper-mid)
Available locally at: Raymour & Flanigan in Olean (802 W State St), Ashley Store in Olean (1429 Olean-Portville Rd), and Metro Mattress Olean (3061 W State St)

Serta

Serta has built a strong reputation around motion isolation and pressure relief, particularly in their iComfort and Perfect Sleeper lines. Their hybrid models are popular with couples because one partner moving around at night is far less likely to disturb the other. You can find Serta at three Olean locations, which means more chances to test different firmness levels before committing.

Best for: Couples, side sleepers dealing with shoulder or hip pressure, and anyone who runs warm at night
Price Range: $$ - $$$ (Mid-range to upper-mid)
Available locally at: Raymour & Flanigan in Olean (802 W State St), Ollie's Bargain Outlet in Olean (2801 W State St), and Ashley Store in Olean (1429 Olean-Portville Rd)

Chattam & Wells

Chattam & Wells sits at the luxury end of what's available in Olean. These are handcrafted innerspring and hybrid mattresses built with high-quality materials - think individually wrapped coils, natural fibers, and multiple comfort layers. If you've been sleeping on a mid-range mattress for years and want to understand what the step up actually feels like, this is one worth trying in person.

Best for: Luxury comfort seekers, side sleepers who want plush pressure relief without sacrificing support
Price Range: $$$$ - Luxury
Available locally at: Mattress Xtreme in Olean (1657 Olean-Portville Rd) and Metro Mattress Olean (3061 W State St)

Dura-Last

Dura-Last is a brand focused specifically on long-term durability, which makes it a practical choice for people who have replaced mattresses more often than they'd like. The construction emphasizes materials that hold their shape and support over time rather than softening prematurely. It's not the flashiest brand on this list, but it's a solid pick if you want a mattress that stays consistent for years.

Best for: Buyers prioritizing longevity, back sleepers who need consistent support night after night
Price Range: $$ - $$$ (Mid-range)
Available locally at: Mattress Xtreme in Olean (1657 Olean-Portville Rd) and Metro Mattress Olean (3061 W State St)

Simmons

Simmons, maker of the Beautyrest line, is well known for its pocketed coil technology, which allows each spring to respond independently to weight and movement. This design significantly reduces motion transfer, which is why it's a perennial recommendation for couples. Their hybrid models pair those coils with foam or gel comfort layers, giving you a mix of bounce and pressure relief.

Best for: Couples needing motion isolation, combination sleepers who shift positions through the night
Price Range: $$ - $$$ (Mid-range to upper-mid)
Available locally at: Raymour & Flanigan in Olean (802 W State St) and Ashley Store in Olean (1429 Olean-Portville Rd)

Spring Air

Spring Air offers a reliable range of innerspring and hybrid mattresses at prices that won't stretch most budgets. The brand has been around since 1926 and focuses on accessible comfort with decent support, making it a reasonable starting point for first-time mattress buyers or those furnishing a guest room. Both Olean retailers carrying Spring Air specialize in mattresses, so the staff can help you compare it side by side with other options.

Best for: Value-focused buyers, guest rooms, first-time mattress shoppers looking for dependable quality
Price Range: $ - $$ (Budget to mid-range)
Available locally at: Mattress Xtreme in Olean (1657 Olean-Portville Rd) and Metro Mattress Olean (3061 W State St)

Stearns & Foster

Stearns & Foster is the luxury brand under the Sealy parent company, and the quality difference is noticeable in person. These mattresses use premium materials including high-density foams, individually wrapped coils, and hand-tufted covers. If Chattam & Wells or Sealy's upper tiers appeal to you, Stearns & Foster is worth comparing directly. Both Olean retailers carry the line, so you can test different models.

Best for: Luxury buyers, side and back sleepers who want both plush feel and firm underlying support
Price Range: $$$$ - Luxury
Available locally at: Raymour & Flanigan in Olean (802 W State St) and Ashley Store in Olean (1429 Olean-Portville Rd)

Ashley Sleep

Ashley Sleep is Ashley Furniture's own mattress brand, sold exclusively through the Ashley Store in Olean. The lineup covers memory foam, hybrid, and innerspring options at very accessible price points, which makes it a practical choice when you're furnishing a room on a tighter budget. The quality-to-price ratio here is genuinely good, especially for kids' rooms or secondary bedrooms.

Best for: Budget-conscious buyers, secondary bedrooms, teenagers and college students
Price Range: $ - $$ (Budget to mid-range)
Available locally at: Ashley Store in Olean (1429 Olean-Portville Rd)

Bellanest

Bellanest is Raymour & Flanigan's exclusive house brand, meaning the only place in Olean to find it is their W State St location. These mattresses are designed and priced to give solid competition to national mid-range brands, often at a slightly lower cost. Because they're exclusive to Raymour & Flanigan, the staff there tends to know the line well and can walk you through firmness options clearly.

Best for: Mid-range comfort seekers who want good value without moving into the luxury tier
Price Range: $$ - Mid-range
Available locally at: Raymour & Flanigan in Olean (802 W State St)

Back Supporter

Back Supporter is a brand built around one specific promise: spinal alignment. Their mattresses are engineered with orthopedic support in mind, using zoned coil systems or foam layers designed to reduce lower back pressure. It's available only at Metro Mattress Olean, which carries it alongside other specialty brands, so the staff there can help you determine whether the firmness profile matches your sleep position.

Best for: People with lower back pain, back sleepers who need targeted lumbar support
Price Range: $$ - $$$ (Mid-range)
Available locally at: Metro Mattress Olean (3061 W State St)

Understanding Mattress Types and Sleep Health

Memory Foam for Pressure Relief

Memory foam mattresses contour closely to your body, which distributes weight more evenly across your shoulders, hips, and lower back. This is especially helpful for side sleepers, because sleeping on your side concentrates a significant amount of pressure on the hip and shoulder on the lower side. Research on side sleepers consistently shows that pressure relief at those contact points is the top priority for comfort and uninterrupted sleep. The main trade-off with traditional memory foam is heat retention, which is why newer gel-infused or open-cell foam versions exist across several of the brands on this list.

Hybrid Mattresses for Support and Comfort

A hybrid mattress combines an innerspring coil base with one or more foam or latex comfort layers on top. The coil system provides a responsive, supportive base that keeps your spine aligned, while the foam layers add cushioning and reduce motion transfer. Spinal health research suggests that the combination of support and pressure relief in hybrid designs can be particularly effective for people who shift positions during the night. Brands like Simmons, Sealy, and Serta all offer well-regarded hybrids you can test at Olean retailers.

Innerspring for Traditional Sleepers

Innerspring mattresses remain popular because they sleep cooler than foam options - the open coil structure allows more airflow through the mattress core. They also offer a traditional bouncy feel that many sleepers prefer, especially stomach sleepers who need a firmer surface that won't let their hips sink too deep. The trade-off is motion isolation. Coil systems generally transfer more movement between sleep partners than foam does, though pocketed coil systems (like those in Simmons Beautyrest) reduce this significantly. Spring Air, Chattam & Wells, and Stearns & Foster all have strong innerspring options available locally.

Firmness and Sleep Position

Firmness is one of the most misunderstood factors in mattress shopping. Softer is not always better for comfort, and firmer is not always better for back pain. The right firmness depends almost entirely on how you sleep. Published research on mattresses and back pain found that medium-firm mattresses tend to produce the best outcomes for lower back pain, particularly for back sleepers. Side sleepers typically do better with a medium to medium-soft feel that allows hips and shoulders to sink slightly and maintain a neutral spine. Stomach sleepers need a firmer surface to prevent lumbar hyperextension. Use our mattress buying guide to match your sleep position to the right firmness range before you shop, and take the mattress size calculator with you when you're ready to decide on dimensions.

Where to Buy These Brands Locally

Olean has a surprisingly strong local mattress retail presence for a city its size. You'll find five distinct retailers spread across W State St and Olean-Portville Rd, with each one carrying a different mix of brands and price points. Here's a quick breakdown of where to go based on what you're looking for.

Raymour & Flanigan on W State St carries the largest brand variety of any single Olean retailer, with Sealy, Serta, Simmons, Stearns & Foster, and Bellanest all on the floor. It's the best starting point if you want to compare multiple brands in one visit. Metro Mattress Olean on W State St specializes in mattresses only, carries Sealy, Chattam & Wells, Dura-Last, Spring Air, and Back Supporter, and typically has staff with focused mattress knowledge. Mattress Xtreme on Olean-Portville Rd is another mattress-focused retailer carrying Chattam & Wells, Dura-Last, and Spring Air - great if you want to focus on that mid-range to luxury segment. The Ashley Store covers Sealy, Serta, Simmons, Stearns & Foster, and Ashley Sleep in one location. Before you visit any of them, run through the mattress buying checklist so you're comparing each store on the same criteria.

Prefer Shopping Online?

If you'd rather skip the store visits, Sleepology offers a compelling alternative. They carry many premium mattress brands with commission-free pricing (no sales commissions added to prices), a "double-the-difference" price match guarantee, and their Price Predictor™ tool ensures you're getting the best deal. It's a transparent, no-pressure shopping experience with white-glove delivery. Use code DELIVERY for free delivery: