Best Mattress Brands in Amherst, New York [2026 Guide]

Quick Brand Comparison

Here's a quick overview of the top mattress brands available locally in Amherst, New York. This comparison will help you identify which brands align with your sleep needs and budget before visiting local retailers.

Brand	Best For	Price Range	Local Retailers
Stearns & Foster	Luxury comfort seekers	$$$ - Luxury	City Mattress, Mattress Firm
Beautyrest	Motion isolation needs	$$ - Mid-range	City Mattress, Ashley Store
Tempur-Pedic	Pressure point relief	$$$ - Premium	City Mattress, Bob's Discount
Purple	Hot sleepers	$$ - Mid-range	Mattress Firm, Ashley Store
Sealy	All sleep positions	$ - Budget-friendly	City Mattress, Raymour & Flanigan
Restonic	Traditional spring comfort	$ - Value	Bob's Discount, Raymour & Flanigan
Aireloom	Handcrafted luxury	$$$ - Ultra-premium	City Mattress, Raymour & Flanigan
Sleepy's by Sealy	Budget-conscious buyers	$ - Entry-level	Mattress Firm
King Koil	Spinal alignment	$$ - Mid-range	City Mattress, Bob's Discount
Tulo Bamboo	Eco-conscious sleepers	$ - Affordable	Mattress Firm

Best Mattress Brands Available in Amherst

Amherst residents have access to some of the most respected mattress brands in the industry. Each brand offers unique benefits for different sleep preferences and health needs. Here are the top mattress brands you can test and purchase locally.

Stearns & Foster

Stearns & Foster represents the pinnacle of luxury mattress craftsmanship, combining premium materials like silk, cashmere, and high-grade memory foams. This brand specializes in handcrafted mattresses that provide exceptional support and comfort for discerning sleepers. With over 170 years of experience, Stearns & Foster mattresses are built to last and offer superior edge support.

Best for: Luxury seekers who want premium materials and exceptional durability
Price Range: $$$ - Luxury ($1,500-$4,000+)
Available locally at: City Mattress in Amherst and Mattress Firm on Transit Road

Beautyrest

Beautyrest revolutionized the mattress industry with their individually wrapped coil technology, which provides exceptional motion isolation and personalized support. Their Black and Silver collections offer different firmness levels and cooling technologies. The pocketed coil system adapts to your body's contours while minimizing partner disturbance throughout the night.

Best for: Couples who need motion isolation and personalized support
Price Range: $$ - Mid-range ($800-$2,500)
Available locally at: City Mattress in Amherst and Ashley Store on Alberta Drive

Tempur-Pedic

Tempur-Pedic pioneered memory foam mattresses using NASA-developed pressure-relieving material. Their proprietary TEMPUR material responds to your body's temperature, weight, and shape to provide personalized support and pressure relief. This brand is particularly beneficial for people with joint pain or pressure point sensitivity.

Best for: Side sleepers with pressure point pain and those needing conforming support
Price Range: $$$ - Premium ($1,200-$4,000+)
Available locally at: City Mattress in Amherst and Bob's Discount Furniture on Sheridan Drive

Purple

Purple mattresses feature a unique gel grid technology that promotes airflow and temperature regulation while providing responsive support. The hyper-elastic polymer grid flexes to support pressure points while maintaining firm support for heavier body parts. This innovative design makes Purple particularly effective for hot sleepers who struggle with traditional memory foam.

Best for: Hot sleepers who need cooling comfort and responsive support
Price Range: $$ - Mid-range ($900-$2,200)
Available locally at: Mattress Firm on Transit Road and Ashley Store on Alberta Drive

Sealy

Sealy offers a comprehensive range of mattresses from budget-friendly options to premium models, including their famous Posturepedic line. Their mattresses feature targeted support zones that align with your body's natural curves. Sealy's diverse lineup includes memory foam, hybrid, and innerspring options to accommodate different sleep preferences and budgets.

Best for: All sleep positions with targeted support needs and budget-conscious shoppers
Price Range: $ - Budget-friendly ($400-$1,800)
Available locally at: City Mattress in Amherst and Raymour & Flanigan on Niagara Falls Boulevard

Restonic

Restonic has been crafting quality mattresses since 1938, focusing on traditional innerspring construction with modern comfort enhancements. Their mattresses feature individually wrapped coils combined with various comfort layers including gel memory foam and natural latex. Restonic offers excellent value with durable construction and reliable support.

Best for: Traditional spring feel lovers who want modern comfort enhancements
Price Range: $ - Value ($500-$1,500)
Available locally at: Bob's Discount Furniture on Sheridan Drive and Raymour & Flanigan on Niagara Falls Boulevard

Aireloom

Aireloom represents ultra-luxury mattress craftsmanship, with each mattress hand-tufted and made using premium natural materials like organic cotton, wool, and latex. Founded in California, Aireloom mattresses are known for their exceptional durability and luxurious feel. The brand's patented Aireloom Lift technology provides unique support and comfort.

Best for: Luxury enthusiasts who appreciate handcrafted quality and natural materials
Price Range: $$$ - Ultra-premium ($2,000-$6,000+)
Available locally at: City Mattress in Amherst and Raymour & Flanigan on Niagara Falls Boulevard

Sleepy's by Sealy

Sleepy's by Sealy offers budget-friendly mattresses without compromising on basic comfort and support features. This value-oriented line provides essential sleep comfort with simplified construction and materials. The brand focuses on delivering reliable sleep solutions for cost-conscious consumers who still want quality construction.

Best for: Budget-conscious buyers who need reliable basic comfort and support
Price Range: $ - Entry-level ($300-$900)
Available locally at: Mattress Firm on Transit Road

King Koil

King Koil specializes in mattresses designed with chiropractic principles in mind, featuring their Perfect Contour Reaction coil system for optimal spinal alignment. The brand has been endorsed by the International Chiropractors Association for their commitment to proper sleep posture. King Koil mattresses combine supportive innerspring systems with comfort layers that maintain healthy sleep alignment.

Best for: Back pain sufferers and those prioritizing spinal alignment and chiropractic support
Price Range: $$ - Mid-range ($600-$2,000)
Available locally at: City Mattress in Amherst and Bob's Discount Furniture on Sheridan Drive

Tulo Bamboo

Tulo Bamboo focuses on eco-friendly sleep solutions using sustainable bamboo-derived materials and plant-based foams. This environmentally conscious brand offers simplified mattress options with natural antimicrobial properties and temperature regulation. Tulo combines environmental responsibility with comfortable, affordable sleep solutions.

Best for: Eco-conscious sleepers who want sustainable materials and natural antimicrobial properties
Price Range: $ - Affordable ($400-$1,000)
Available locally at: Mattress Firm on Transit Road

Understanding Mattress Types and Sleep Health

Choosing the right mattress type is essential for optimal sleep health and comfort. Different mattress constructions offer unique benefits that can address specific sleep issues and preferences. Understanding these differences will help you make an informed decision for your sleep needs.

Memory Foam for Pressure Relief

Memory foam mattresses excel at contouring to your body's shape, distributing weight evenly and reducing pressure points. This makes them particularly beneficial for side sleepers who experience hip and shoulder pressure. Research shows that medium-firm memory foam can significantly reduce back pain by maintaining proper spinal alignment while cushioning pressure points. The material's viscoelastic properties respond to body heat, creating a personalized sleep surface that adapts throughout the night.

Hybrid Mattresses for Support and Comfort

Hybrid mattresses combine the support of innerspring coils with the comfort of memory foam or latex layers, making them ideal for combination sleepers who change positions throughout the night. The coil system provides responsive support and better airflow, while comfort layers offer pressure relief. Sleep experts note that hybrid construction can provide optimal spinal support for various sleep positions, making them versatile choices for couples with different preferences.

Innerspring for Traditional Sleepers

Traditional innerspring mattresses offer firm support with excellent airflow and temperature regulation. The coil system provides responsive support that maintains its shape night after night, making these mattresses particularly suitable for stomach sleepers and those who prefer a firmer sleep surface. Modern innerspring designs feature individually wrapped coils that reduce motion transfer while maintaining the traditional bouncy feel that many sleepers prefer.

Firmness and Sleep Position

Mattress firmness plays a critical role in sleep quality and spinal health. Side sleepers typically benefit from medium to medium-soft firmnesses that allow hips and shoulders to sink in while supporting the waist. Back sleepers generally need medium to medium-firm support to maintain the spine's natural curve. Studies indicate that proper firmness selection based on sleep position can significantly improve sleep quality and reduce morning stiffness. Before making a decision, use our size guide to ensure you're selecting the right mattress dimensions for your space and comfort needs.

Where to Buy These Brands Locally

Amherst offers several reputable mattress retailers where you can test and purchase these quality brands. The town's location near Buffalo provides access to major mattress chains and specialty stores, giving you plenty of options to compare brands and prices in person.

City Mattress on Sheridan Drive carries the widest selection of premium brands including Stearns & Foster, Tempur-Pedic, and Aireloom. Their knowledgeable staff can help you navigate different comfort levels and technologies. Mattress Firm on Transit Road offers competitive pricing on popular brands like Purple and Beautyrest, often with promotional financing options. For value-conscious shoppers, Bob's Discount Furniture on Sheridan Drive provides quality brands at discounted prices.

When visiting local stores, bring our mattress buying checklist to ensure you evaluate each option thoroughly. Most retailers offer sleep trials, so don't hesitate to take advantage of these policies to ensure your chosen mattress works well in your home environment.

Prefer Shopping Online?

If you'd rather skip the store visits, Sleepology offers a compelling alternative. They carry many premium mattress brands with commission-free pricing (no sales commissions added to prices), a "double-the-difference" price match guarantee, and their Price Predictor™ tool ensures you're getting the best deal. It's a transparent, no-pressure shopping experience with white-glove delivery. Use code DELIVERY for free delivery: Shop Sleepology.