Best Mattress Stores in Evansville, Indiana [2026 Guide]

Quick Mattress Store Comparisons

Here's a quick overview of Evansville's top mattress retailers to help you narrow down your options before visiting.

Top Mattress Stores in Evansville

Evansville Overstock Warehouse Furniture & Mattress

This local warehouse operation specializes in discounted name-brand mattresses and furniture pieces that other retailers couldn't move. You'll find genuine brand names at significantly reduced prices, though selection varies based on what's available.

Queens typically start around $400-600 for quality brands that would cost $800+ elsewhere. The trade-off is limited selection and "as-is" inventory, but the savings are real.

Best for: Budget-conscious shoppers who don't mind limited selection
Contact: 201 N Green River Rd, Evansville, IN 47715
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-812-205-2746

Ashley Store

The local Ashley Store focuses exclusively on Ashley's mattress lines, including their popular Chime series and higher-end memory foam options. They frequently run promotions and offer solid financing deals for qualified buyers.

Queen mattresses range from $300 for basic innerspring models up to $1,200 for their premium memory foam collections. Their Chime series offers good value in the $400-600 range.

Best for: Shoppers who prefer brand consistency and promotional deals
Contact: 1441 N Green River Rd, Evansville, IN 47715
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-812-471-2090

Denver Mattress

Denver Mattress operates as a factory-direct retailer, cutting out middleman markups on their own manufactured products. Their showroom offers a good range of firmness levels and sleep technologies without the premium pricing of major brands.

Factory-direct queens start around $500 and top out around $1,100 for their most advanced models. Their "Doctor's Choice" line provides good support for back pain sufferers.

Best for: Quality-focused shoppers who want good value without brand premiums
Contact: 445 Circle Front Dr, Evansville, IN 47715
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-812-476-7505

Big Sandy Superstore - Evansville

Big Sandy operates as a regional furniture and mattress chain with a massive showroom that stocks multiple major brands. Their selection includes everything from budget options to luxury models, making it easy to comparison shop under one roof.

Queen prices span from $350 for basic models to $2,000+ for luxury brands like Tempur-Pedic and Sealy Posturepedic. They often match competitor pricing and offer extended payment plans.

Best for: Shoppers who want extensive selection and competitive pricing
Contact: 5476 E Indiana St, Evansville, IN 47715
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-812-602-5960

Furniture Row

Furniture Row combines mattress shopping with complete bedroom furniture, making it convenient for customers planning room makeovers. They carry their own Denver Mattress brand alongside other manufacturers and frequently offer package deals.

Queens range from $500-1,200 for standalone mattresses, but their real value comes from bedroom set packages that can save hundreds compared to buying pieces separately.

Best for: Customers planning complete bedroom renovations
Contact: 445 Circle Front Dr, Evansville, IN 47715
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-812-473-1070

Bosler's Furniture & Mattress

Bosler's has served the Evansville area for decades with a focus on personal customer service and quality brands. Their sales staff tends to be more consultative than pushy, and they maintain long-term relationships with customers.

Queen mattresses typically range from $600-1,800 depending on brand and features. They carry respected names like Sealy and Serta, and often throw in free delivery and setup within Evansville.

Best for: Shoppers who value personal service and long-term local relationships
Contact: 3820 E Morgan Ave, Evansville, IN 47715
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-812-476-8787

Delivery Considerations

Most Evansville mattress stores offer delivery within a 25-mile radius, though fees and timing vary significantly. Expect to pay $50-150 for standard delivery, with some stores offering free delivery on purchases over $500-1,000. Delivery windows typically span 3-7 business days, though custom orders may take 2-4 weeks.

Many retailers provide white-glove service (setup and packaging removal) for an additional $50-75, which is usually worth it for heavier mattresses or if you live in an apartment. Some stores also offer old mattress haul-away service for $25-50. Before making your purchase, use our pre-purchase checklist to ensure you've covered all delivery details and associated costs.

Mattress Buying Guide

Understanding Firmness Levels

Mattress firmness significantly impacts sleep quality, but there's no universal standard between brands. What one manufacturer calls "medium" might feel firm to another brand's standards. The key is testing mattresses in person rather than relying solely on firmness descriptions.

Side sleepers typically need softer surfaces (3-6 on a 10-point scale) to accommodate hip and shoulder curves, while back and stomach sleepers often prefer firmer support (6-8). However, your weight and personal preference matter more than general guidelines. Most couples find success in the medium-firm range (5-6) as a compromise.

Size Selection Strategy

Queen mattresses work for most couples, but consider your bedroom size and sleep habits before deciding. If either partner is over 6'2" or you have restless sleepers, a king might be worth the extra investment. Measure your bedroom and doorways first - some older Evansville homes have narrow staircases that won't accommodate king mattresses.

Twin XL works well for teenagers and guest rooms, offering extra length without taking up more floor space. Full-size mattresses are becoming less popular for couples since they provide only 27 inches of width per person. Our mattress size guide includes specific measurements and room size recommendations to help you choose wisely.

Budget Planning

A quality mattress should last 7-10 years, making it worth investing in better materials and construction. Budget at least $600-800 for a queen-size mattress that will provide consistent support and comfort. Cheaper mattresses often develop impressions and lose support within 2-3 years, making them more expensive long-term.

Factor in additional costs like delivery ($50-100), setup service ($50-75), and mattress protection ($100-200 for a quality protector). Many stores offer financing, but compare interest rates carefully. Sometimes it's better to save up and pay cash, especially during major sale events like Memorial Day or Labor Day weekends.

Prefer Shopping Online?

If you'd rather skip the showroom experience, Sleepology offers a compelling online alternative with several advantages over traditional retail. Their commission-free pricing means no sales markup, and their "Double-the-difference" price match guarantee ensures you get the best deal available. The Price Predictor™ tool helps verify you're buying at optimal pricing, while their curated selection includes only premium mattress brands without overwhelming choices.

What sets Sleepology apart is their educational approach - you get transparent guidance without high-pressure sales tactics common in mattress stores. They offer in-home white glove delivery and setup, plus you can get free delivery with code DELIVERY. For Evansville residents who value convenience and transparent pricing, Sleepology's online approach eliminates the hassle while often providing better prices than local showrooms.