Best Mattress Stores in Mansfield, Ohio [2026 Guide]

Quick Mattress Store Comparisons

Shopping for a mattress in Mansfield doesn't have to be overwhelming. I've spent time visiting our local stores and talking with neighbors about their experiences. Whether you're near the Ohio State Reformatory or out by Kingwood Center Gardens, these six stores offer the best combination of selection, service, and value for Mansfield families.

Top Mattress Stores in Mansfield

Ashley Store

Ashley Store on North Lexington-Springmill Road is your go-to for coordinated bedroom sets that look like they belong in a magazine. They carry their own Ashley-Sleep line alongside traditional furniture pieces, making it easy to outfit your entire bedroom in one trip.

Queen mattresses typically start around $450, with their premium hybrid models reaching $1,800. The store frequently runs promotions on bedroom packages that can save you hundreds when buying a mattress with a frame and dresser.

Best for: Couples redesigning their bedroom with matching furniture
Contact: 919 N Lexington-Springmill Rd, Mansfield, OH 44906
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-419-747-4040

Ollie's Bargin Outlet

Don't overlook Ollie's on Lexington Avenue when mattress shopping on a tight budget. Their inventory rotates based on manufacturer overstock, so you might find a name-brand queen for under $400 that would cost double elsewhere.

Selection varies weekly, but I've seen quality memory foam and innerspring mattresses from recognizable brands priced between $200-$800. The catch is limited sizes and styles, so flexibility helps when shopping here.

Best for: Budget-conscious shoppers willing to be flexible on brand and style
Contact: 1414 Lexington Ave, Mansfield, OH 44906
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-419-774-8936

Furniture Row

Located on Walker Lake Road, Furniture Row operates as a furniture superstore where you can handle everything from mattresses to living room sets. Their mattress selection focuses on mid-range comfort without the premium pricing of specialty sleep stores.

Queens start around $450 with their better models reaching $1,600. They offer decent financing options and their sales staff knows furniture well, though they're not sleep specialists like you'd find at dedicated mattress stores.

Best for: Families furnishing multiple rooms who want convenience and reasonable prices
Contact: 2039 Walker Lake Rd, Mansfield, OH 44903
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-419-747-2879

Denver Mattress

Denver Mattress shares the Walker Lake Road location with Furniture Row but operates as a dedicated sleep store. They manufacture many of their own mattresses, which means better prices since you're buying factory-direct without middleman markups.

Their queen mattresses range from $500 to $2,000, with several models made right here in the Midwest. The staff really knows sleep technology and can explain the differences between their various foam densities and coil systems.

Best for: Shoppers wanting quality construction and knowledgeable staff without luxury store pricing
Contact: 2039 Walker Lake Rd, Mansfield, OH 44903
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-419-747-4013

Mattress Firm Mansfield

The Mattress Firm on North Lexington-Springmill Road offers the largest selection in town with over 30 mattresses on display from brands like Tempur-Pedic, Sealy, and Serta. Their sleep specialists spend time understanding your preferences and sleep issues before making recommendations.

Pricing ranges from $600 for basic queens up to $2,500 for luxury models. They offer 90-night sleep trials and will work with you if the mattress isn't quite right, which provides peace of mind for such a big purchase.

Best for: Shoppers who want extensive selection, sleep trials, and specialized guidance
Contact: 898 N Lexington-Springmill Rd, Mansfield, OH 44906
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-419-747-5600

ABC Warehouse

ABC Warehouse on West 4th Street is primarily an appliance and electronics store, but they carry a basic selection of mattresses that work well for guest rooms or kids' bedrooms. Don't expect luxury, but their prices are hard to beat for simple, functional sleep surfaces.

Queen mattresses start around $300 and top out near $1,200 for their best models. The selection is limited compared to dedicated furniture stores, but the prices reflect the no-frills approach.

Best for: Budget shoppers needing basic comfort for spare bedrooms or temporary situations
Contact: 2360 W 4th St, Mansfield, OH 44906
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1-419-747-1260

Delivery Considerations

Most Mansfield mattress stores offer delivery within Richland County, typically charging $75-$150 depending on your distance from town. If you live near Ontario or Lexington, expect to pay on the lower end, while rural deliveries toward Butler or Lucas might cost more.

Delivery windows usually span 2-4 hours, so plan accordingly. Ashley Store and Mattress Firm offer white glove delivery that includes setup and old mattress removal for an additional fee. Before scheduling delivery, use our mattress buying checklist to ensure you've considered all the important factors.

Most stores will haul away your old mattress for $25-$50, which is worth it since Richland County Solid Waste Management has specific disposal requirements for mattresses. Some stores include haul-away free with purchases over certain amounts, so ask when negotiating your deal.

Mattress Buying Guide

Understanding Firmness Levels

Firmness preference is highly personal, but most Mansfield couples find medium-firm mattresses work best for our climate and lifestyle. Memory foam tends to sleep warmer, which some locals love during our cold winters but might find less comfortable in summer.

Try lying on mattresses for at least 10-15 minutes in your typical sleep position. Don't let salespeople rush you - this is a major purchase that affects your sleep for years. If you're shopping with a partner, both of you should test the mattress together since weight and sleep positions interact differently.

Size Selection Strategy

Queen size remains the most popular choice for Mansfield homes, fitting well in most master bedrooms while providing adequate space for couples. However, if you're over six feet tall or have a partner who tosses and turns, consider measuring your current bed to see if you'd benefit from a king.

Before deciding on size, measure your bedroom doorways and stairwells. Many Mansfield homes built before 1960 have narrower hallways that can make king delivery challenging. Our mattress size guide includes measurement tips and space requirements for each size.

Budget Planning

Plan to spend $800-$1,200 for a quality queen mattress that will last 8-10 years in our climate. Cheaper mattresses often use lower-quality foams that break down faster, while spending over $2,000 usually provides minimal additional comfort for most people.

Don't forget to budget for a mattress protector ($50-$100) and potentially new pillows ($30-$150 each) since your sleep setup works as a system. Many stores offer package deals that include these accessories at a discount. Check our mattress cost calculator to see how different price points affect your cost per night of sleep.

Prefer Shopping Online?

If you'd rather skip the store visits and sales pressure, Sleepology offers a compelling online alternative for Mansfield residents. They focus on commission-free pricing, which means no sales commissions are added to your mattress cost, and their "double-the-difference" price match guarantee ensures you're getting the best deal available.

What sets Sleepology apart is their Price Predictor tool that helps ensure optimal pricing and their transparent, education-focused approach without high-pressure tactics. They carry premium mattress brands all in one place and offer white glove delivery service. Mansfield customers can use code DELIVERY for free delivery, making it easy to get quality sleep delivered right to your door. Get free delivery with code DELIVERY.