Quick Mattress Store Comparisons
Here's a quick overview of the best mattress stores serving Reynoldsburg residents. Each offers something different, so you can find the right fit for your sleep needs and budget.
| Store Name | Specialty | Price Range | Best For |
|---|
| Big Sandy Superstore | Furniture & Mattresses | $300-$2,000+ | One-stop shopping |
| Ashley Store | Brand Name Furniture | $400-$3,000+ | Matching bedroom sets |
| Mattress Firm Slate Ridge | Sleep Specialization | $200-$4,000+ | Sleep trials & warranties |
| Waterbeds 'n' Stuff | Alternative Sleep Systems | $250-$2,500+ | Unique sleep solutions |
| Bob's Discount Furniture | Value Pricing | $200-$1,500+ | Budget-conscious shoppers |
| Sleep Outfitters | Premium Sleep Products | $500-$5,000+ | Luxury mattresses |
Top Mattress Stores in Reynoldsburg
Big Sandy Superstore
This full-service furniture and mattress store has been serving central Ohio families for years with a solid selection of name-brand and house-brand mattresses. They're known for competitive pricing and frequent sales events that can save you hundreds on quality sleep sets.
You'll find everything from budget-friendly innerspring mattresses starting around $300 for a queen to premium memory foam and hybrid models reaching $2,000 or more. Their sales team is helpful without being pushy, and they offer flexible financing options.
Best for: Families looking to furnish multiple rooms or shoppers who want furniture and mattresses in one trip
Contact: 2644 Taylor Rd SW, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 614-892-7575
Ashley Store
The Ashley HomeStore location on Taylor Park Drive brings the national furniture brand's mattress selection right to Reynoldsburg. They specialize in coordinated bedroom collections, so you can match your new mattress with nightstands, dressers, and bed frames.
Their mattress lineup includes Ashley's own sleep brand as well as partnerships with major manufacturers. Queen mattresses typically start around $400, with their premium collections reaching $3,000 or more for advanced cooling and support technologies.
Best for: Shoppers wanting coordinated bedroom furniture or those loyal to the Ashley brand
Contact: 2339 Taylor Park Dr, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 614-452-4250
Mattress Firm Slate Ridge
As the nation's largest mattress retailer, Mattress Firm brings serious sleep expertise to Reynoldsburg. Their Baltimore-Reynoldsburg Road location stocks major brands like Tempur-Pedic, Serta, Beautyrest, and Purple, plus their own exclusive lines.
What sets them apart is their 120-night sleep trial and extensive warranty programs. Queens start around $200 for basic models, but most shoppers gravitate toward the $800-$2,000 range for quality memory foam and hybrid options.
Best for: Shoppers who want extensive brand selection and generous sleep trials
Contact: 2032 Baltimore-Reynoldsburg Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 614-755-4706
Waterbeds 'n' Stuff
Don't let the name fool you - while they still carry waterbeds, this local chain has evolved into a full-service mattress store with some unique options you won't find elsewhere. They're particularly strong in adjustable beds and specialty sleep systems for people with specific comfort needs.
Their conventional mattress selection covers all the bases, with queens starting around $250. But where they really shine is in custom solutions and alternative sleep systems that can help with back pain, sleep apnea, or other issues.
Best for: Shoppers with specific sleep challenges or those interested in adjustable bed systems
Contact: 2177 OH-256, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 614-861-4650
Bob's Discount Furniture and Mattress Store
Bob's built their reputation on "no gimmicks" value pricing, and their Reynoldsburg location delivers on that promise. They cut costs by buying directly from manufacturers and keeping overhead low, then pass those savings on to customers.
Their Bob-O-Pedic mattress line offers solid quality at impressive price points, with queens starting around $200. They also carry name brands, but the real value is in their house brands that often match the quality of premium mattresses at half the price.
Best for: Budget-conscious shoppers who don't want to sacrifice quality for price
Contact: 2686 Taylor Rd Ext, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 380-264-2001
Sleep Outfitters of Reynoldsburg
This regional chain focuses exclusively on sleep products, and their Reynoldsburg location brings a boutique feel to mattress shopping. Their sales associates undergo extensive sleep training and can guide you through their curated selection of premium brands.
They carry luxury lines like Tempur-Pedic, Stearns & Foster, and exclusive collections you won't find at big box stores. Queens typically start around $500, with their premium collections reaching $5,000 for the ultimate in comfort technology.
Best for: Shoppers seeking premium mattresses with expert guidance and personalized service
Contact: 2227 Reynoldsburg-Baltimore Rd Unit B, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 614-610-1810
Delivery Considerations
Most Reynoldsburg mattress stores offer delivery throughout Franklin County, but the details vary significantly. Standard delivery typically costs $50-$100 and includes basic setup in your bedroom. However, delivery windows can be wide (often 4-8 hours), so plan accordingly if you need to be home.
Many stores offer white glove delivery for an additional fee ($75-$150), which includes unpacking, full setup, and removal of packaging materials. This is especially worth it for memory foam mattresses that need time to expand properly. Before you buy, ask about haul-away services for your old mattress - some stores include this free, while others charge $25-$50.
If you're shopping during busy periods like holiday weekends or back-to-school season, expect delivery times to stretch to 1-2 weeks rather than the typical 3-7 days. For urgent replacements, check which stores offer next-day or same-day delivery, though these premium services usually cost extra. Use our mattress buying checklist to ensure you ask about all delivery details before making your purchase.
Mattress Buying Guide
Understanding Firmness Levels
Firmness preferences are highly personal, but there are general guidelines that work for most sleepers. Side sleepers typically need softer surfaces (3-6 on a 1-10 scale) to allow hips and shoulders to sink in properly, while back and stomach sleepers usually prefer medium to firm options (5-8) for better spinal alignment.
Don't rely solely on marketing terms like "plush" or "luxury firm" - these vary between manufacturers. Always test mattresses in person at Reynoldsburg stores, and lie down for at least 10-15 minutes in your normal sleep position. Remember that most mattresses feel different after a few weeks of use than they do in the showroom.
Size Selection Strategy
Queen mattresses remain the most popular choice in Reynoldsburg, offering good space efficiency for most bedrooms while providing comfortable sleep for couples. However, consider your room layout carefully - you'll want at least 24 inches of walking space around the bed.
King size makes sense if you have a master bedroom larger than 12x12 feet, share the bed with pets or children, or if either partner is taller than 6 feet. California kings are great for very tall sleepers but actually provide less total sleeping area than standard kings. Check out our comprehensive mattress size guide for detailed measurements and room planning tips.
Budget Planning
Plan to spend $800-$1,500 for a quality queen mattress that will last 7-10 years, though you can find decent options for less if budget is tight. Remember that price per night of sleep makes expensive mattresses more reasonable - a $1,200 mattress used for 8 years costs about 40 cents per night.
Many Reynoldsburg stores offer 0% financing for 12-48 months, which can make premium mattresses more accessible. However, read the fine print carefully - some deals require paying the full balance before the promotional period ends to avoid retroactive interest charges. Factor in delivery costs, mattress protectors ($50-$150), and potentially new pillows when planning your total investment.
Our mattress cost calculator can help you determine a realistic budget based on your sleep priorities and financial situation. Don't forget that a good mattress is an investment in your health and daily productivity.
Prefer Shopping Online?
If you'd rather skip the showroom visits, Sleepology offers a compelling online alternative with several advantages over traditional mattress shopping. Their commission-free pricing means no sales pressure or inflated prices, while their "double-the-difference" price match guarantee ensures you're getting the best deal available.
What sets Sleepology apart is their Price Predictor tool that helps you find the optimal purchase timing, plus their transparent, education-focused approach to mattress buying. You'll get premium mattress brands all in one place with clean, no-haggle pricing and white glove delivery right to your Reynoldsburg home. They even offer free delivery with code DELIVERY, making the online experience both convenient and cost-effective compared to traditional retail markup pricing.
![Best Mattress Stores in Reynoldsburg, Ohio [2026 Guide] — hero image](https://euwpgvegcebisxlyfgfx.supabase.co/storage/v1/object/public/blog-images/image-1775063112098.png)
![Best Mattress Stores in Alpharetta, Georgia [2026 Guide]](https://euwpgvegcebisxlyfgfx.supabase.co/storage/v1/object/public/blog-images/image-1776575095035.png)
![Best Mattress Stores in Yonkers, New York [2026 Guide]](https://euwpgvegcebisxlyfgfx.supabase.co/storage/v1/object/public/blog-images/image-1776531911026.png)
![Best Mattress Brands in Yonkers, New York [2026 Guide]](https://euwpgvegcebisxlyfgfx.supabase.co/storage/v1/object/public/blog-images/image-1776531988599.png)
![Best Mattress Stores in Reynoldsburg, Ohio [2026 Guide] — showroom image](https://euwpgvegcebisxlyfgfx.supabase.co/storage/v1/object/public/blog-images/gallery-best-mattress-stores-reynoldsburg-ohio-1775063056576.png)
![Best Mattress Brands in Waldorf, Maryland [2026 Guide]](https://euwpgvegcebisxlyfgfx.supabase.co/storage/v1/object/public/blog-images/image-1776488789755.png)