Mattress Firm Mayfair in Wauwatosa - Reviews, Hours, & Deals

What Your Neighbors Say

Real Google reviews from nearby shoppers

Average rating 4.8 · 593 reviews

Last updated Aug 29, 2026

Mary O'Connell· 5★ · 2026-07-14T20:05:34.491525978Z

Good experience! John was very well informed and could anticipate my needs. I wasn't rushed and left there feeling satisfied. Looking forward to delivery. Mattress Firm is fortunate to have John to work with customers. Thank you.

View on Google

Madeline [Ebert] Masterson· 5★ · 2026-06-04T00:16:20.504164370Z

We had a fantastic experience working with John at the Mayfair Mattress Firm. My husband and I tend to take our time when making big purchases, and John was incredibly patient with us. He never made us feel rushed and took the time to thoroughly explain the different mattress options, helping us understand the pros and cons of each. What we especially appreciated was how knowledgeable he was - not only about the products themselves, but also about his own experiences and feedback from other customers. Those insights were really helpful as we worked through our decision. Once we made our choice, John helped to make the delivery process easy and efficient. We got everything scheduled quickly. He was friendly, professional, informative, and completely non-pressuring from start to finish. If you’re looking for someone who is knowledgeable, patient, and genuinely focused on helping you find the right mattress, we highly recommend John and the team over on Mayfair!

View on Google

D W· 5★ · 2026-07-08T21:23:35.992447521Z

Near Mayfair location- Experience extremely smooth. Very laid back process. Very attentive yet gave space to choose. Great communication through entire process and I love my mattress. Thank God because it took me forever to pick one.

View on Google

Justin Gordon· 5★ · 2026-05-23T12:43:56.731249463Z

I came during their Memorial Day weekend sale hoping to catch a deal on a great mattress. I love that they were able to study me to see which mattress was best for the way I slept. I was able to sample different several brands before landing on the one that was perfect for me. Thank you to John for an amazing experience!

View on Google

Robert Groover· 5★ · 2026-04-12T21:48:28.291587629Z

John was amazing! I never have had such an education on the newer technology available. I absolutely would recommend anyone looking at a new Bed setup, and crazy awesome Adjustable Bed platform, to go to John. It was an amazing experience and I am so happy I Invested my money at the Mayfair store. Please ask for John there as he is truly the expert in the field. He listened to what my needs are and found the best solution for me. Nothing but great things to say!

View on Google

Mattress Firm Mayfair

Brands

Ideal for

Technology

Assortment

Price range