Best Mattress Stores in Amherst, New York [2026 Guide]

Quick Mattress Store Comparisons

Here's a quick overview of Amherst's top mattress retailers to help you narrow down your options before making the drive:

Top Mattress Stores in Amherst

Ashley Store

Located on Alberta Drive, this Ashley HomeStore offers a solid selection of mattresses alongside their furniture collections. They frequently run promotions that bundle mattresses with bedroom furniture, which can save you money if you're furnishing an entire room.

Queen mattresses typically start around $400, with their premium options reaching up to $1,500. They carry their own Ashley-Sleep brand along with Sealy and other popular names.

Best for: Shoppers looking to furnish entire bedrooms
Contact: 575 Alberta Dr, Amherst, NY 14226
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 716-831-9700

Raymour & Flanigan Furniture and Mattress Store

This Niagara Falls Boulevard location has been serving Western New York families for years. Their sales staff knows the local market well and they offer some of the most flexible financing options in town.

Queens start around $500, with their premium Tempur-Pedic and other luxury brands reaching $2,000+. They often have seasonal sales that can save you 20-30% off regular prices.

Best for: Traditional shoppers who want established brands and financing
Contact: 1459 Niagara Fls Blvd, Amherst, NY 14228
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 716-834-7171

Bob's Discount Furniture and Mattress Store

Bob's on Sheridan Drive is your go-to spot for quality mattresses without the premium price tags. Their "Bob-O-Pedic" house brand offers surprisingly good value, and they're known for having mattresses in stock for immediate delivery.

Budget-friendly queens start around $300, with their top-tier options maxing out around $1,200. The no-haggle pricing means you won't feel pressured by aggressive sales tactics.

Best for: Budget-conscious shoppers who want quality without overpaying
Contact: 3058 Sheridan Dr Suite 100, Amherst, NY 14226
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 716-415-5401

City Mattress

City Mattress on Sheridan Drive specializes in premium sleep solutions and has some of the most knowledgeable staff in the area. They carry high-end brands you won't find everywhere, and their sleep consultants really know their stuff.

This is where you'll find luxury brands with queens starting around $600 and premium options reaching $3,000 or more. Their 90-night comfort guarantee gives you peace of mind on larger purchases.

Best for: Sleep quality enthusiasts willing to invest in premium comfort
Contact: 3636 Sheridan Dr, Amherst, NY 14226
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 716-837-6111

Sleep Number

The Sleep Number store offers their signature adjustable firmness mattresses that let each side of the bed have different comfort levels. Perfect for couples who can never agree on mattress firmness, plus their sleep tracking technology appeals to data-driven shoppers.

Prices start around $1,000 for queens and can reach $4,000+ for their most advanced models with all the smart features. The investment makes sense if you value customization and sleep data.

Best for: Couples with different sleep preferences and tech enthusiasts
Contact: 3186-3220 Sheridan Dr Suite 100, Amherst, NY 14226
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 716-210-9223

Mattress Firm 7470 Transit Rd

This Transit Road location offers the largest selection of national brands under one roof. Their frequent sales events and price-matching policy make them competitive, and they usually have good inventory for quick delivery.

Queen mattresses range from about $400 for basic models up to $2,500 for premium memory foam and hybrid options. Their 90-night sleep trial takes the risk out of online-level pricing.

Best for: Shoppers who want maximum brand variety and competitive pricing
Contact: 7470 Transit Rd Suite 100, Amherst, NY 14221
Website: Visit their website
Phone: +1 716-309-5719

Delivery Considerations

Most Amherst mattress stores offer delivery throughout Western New York, but delivery windows and fees vary significantly. Expect to pay $50-150 for delivery depending on the store and your exact location. If you live near the Theodore Roosevelt Inaugural site or closer to downtown Buffalo, you'll likely get faster service than more rural areas.

Several stores offer free delivery on purchases over certain amounts (usually $500-1,000), and many provide haul-away service for your old mattress for an additional $50-100. Bob's and Ashley often have same-day or next-day delivery if you shop early in the week, while Sleep Number typically needs 1-2 weeks for custom orders. When planning your purchase, use our mattress buying checklist to ensure you're asking the right delivery questions upfront.

Mattress Buying Guide

Understanding Firmness Levels

Mattress firmness is rated on a scale from 1 (very soft) to 10 (very firm), with most people finding comfort between 4-7. Side sleepers typically prefer softer mattresses (4-6) that contour to pressure points, while back and stomach sleepers often need firmer support (6-8) for proper spinal alignment.

Don't rely solely on descriptions like "plush" or "firm" since these vary between brands. Always test mattresses in-store by lying in your normal sleep position for at least 10-15 minutes. Your body weight also matters - heavier individuals generally need firmer mattresses to prevent sinking too deeply.

Size Selection Strategy

Queen mattresses work for most couples and fit well in Amherst's typical bedroom sizes, but measure your space first. You need at least 24 inches of walking space around the bed, which means a queen needs roughly a 10x12 foot room to feel comfortable.

King mattresses are great for couples who want extra space but check that they'll fit up your stairs or around tight corners - many Amherst homes built near the Frank Lloyd Wright Martin House era have narrower staircases. Split kings can be easier to maneuver and are perfect if one partner tosses and turns.

For guest rooms or smaller spaces, full mattresses provide decent comfort for single sleepers or occasional couples. Our comprehensive size guide breaks down the exact dimensions and room requirements for each size.

Budget Planning

Plan to spend at least $500-800 for a quality queen mattress that will last 7-10 years. While you can find cheaper options, they often wear out quickly and may not provide adequate support. Factor in delivery fees, mattress protectors, and potentially new pillows when budgeting.

Many stores offer 0% financing, but read the fine print carefully. Some deals require paying off the full amount within 12-18 months to avoid retroactive interest charges. If you're budget-conscious, shop end-of-model sales in January and September when stores clear inventory.

Use our mattress budget calculator to determine what you can comfortably afford, including all accessories and fees. Remember that a good mattress is an investment in your health and daily energy levels.

Prefer Shopping Online?

If you'd rather skip the showroom entirely, consider Sleepology for a completely different mattress buying experience. They focus on commission-free pricing, which means no sales commissions are added to inflate prices. Their "double-the-difference" price match guarantee and Price Predictor™ tool ensure you get the best possible pricing on premium mattress brands.

What sets Sleepology apart is their transparent, education-focused approach without high-pressure salespeople. You get clean, no-haggle pricing with in-home white glove delivery. They offer free delivery with code DELIVERY, making it easy to get quality mattresses delivered right to your Amherst home. Check out their current selection and experience mattress shopping the way it should be.